Jacksonville/ Crime & Emergencies

Jacksonville Mother Sues Officer Who Shot Son Fleeing With Knife During Crisis

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Jacksonville Mother Sues Officer Who Shot Son Fleeing With Knife During CrisisE. 25th St. & Buckman St. — Reported Fatal Encounter Area
Google Street View

Melody Gissentanner filed a federal lawsuit Monday against Jacksonville Sheriff's Office officer Caleb Bumgarner and the City of Jacksonville, alleging her son Brian Gillis was shot and killed while running away and posed no threat when the officer opened fire during a mental health crisis in August 2025. Gillis, a 30-year-old Jacksonville man, died at the scene on East 25th Street near Buckman Street after Bumgarner fired six shots at him as he fled, according to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit, filed Nov. 16, accuses Bumgarner of using excessive and unjustified deadly force against Gillis during what it describes as a documented mental health crisis, according to News4JAX. It includes an excessive-force claim alleging a violation of Gillis' Fourth Amendment rights, along with a wrongful death claim under Florida law against the city. Gissentanner's family is seeking compensatory damages, punitive damages and attorneys' fees.

According to the lawsuit, the morning began when Gissentanner called JSO requesting that officers take her son into custody for a mental health evaluation under Florida's Baker Act. A JSO Behavior Crisis Response Unit officer and a licensed mental health clinician arrived at the family home at 7:43 a.m. that day. Gissentanner told officers her son had a documented mental health history with the department, had been Baker Acted twice before, in 2018 and 2020, and may have suffered a traumatic brain injury years earlier after being accidentally shot in the face, the lawsuit states. She also reported that Gillis had damaged a neighbor's property overnight.

A Foot Chase Ends in Gunfire

While officers were still at the home, Gillis left on foot, and officers searched the neighborhood for more than an hour, the lawsuit says. Bumgarner later spotted Gillis walking on a sidewalk several blocks away at 9:18 a.m. and, per the lawsuit, told him, “Come here or you're going to get dog bit,” before driving to catch up with him. Gillis ran, and Bumgarner drew his Taser after exiting his vehicle.

Gillis stopped and briefly turned around while holding a knife, saying “back up, back up,” before continuing to run away from the officer, according to the lawsuit. Bumgarner put away his Taser, drew his firearm and fired six times as Gillis ran, a sequence first documented in body-camera footage released by News4JAX in August 2025. The lawsuit contends Gillis posed no imminent threat when the shooting occurred and states that no other officers or bystanders were in the area at the time.

The two sides dispute what Gillis was holding. JSO has described the weapon as a large, unsheathed knife, while the lawsuit describes it as a common paring knife with roughly a 3-inch blade. Chief Alan Parker told News4JAX that Gillis pushed the knife in Bumgarner's direction, adding, “At that point, [Bumgarner] goes to lethal force.”

Officer's Record and a Separate Lawsuit

JSO has said Bumgarner had served with the department for 11 years at the time of the shooting and that it was his first officer-involved shooting.

Gillis' shooting was Jacksonville's 13th police shooting of 2025, one of nine that year that proved fatal, and one of seven involving mental-health or suicidal issues, according to The Florida Times-Union. A separate investigation by The Tributary found JSO received 135 use-of-force complaints in a single year, with only two sustained, and that the department has paid out $1.9 million since 2022 to settle use-of-force claims. That review also found officers inconsistently document their use of force and that internal-affairs findings of wrongdoing are rare.

How Jacksonville's Policy Treats Deadly Force

JSO's current Response to Resistance policy, which took effect in July 2026, states that de-escalation techniques should be applied before any use of force when reasonable, and that deadly force is permitted only when de-escalation or less-lethal options would not be reasonable and the force is objectively necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm, according to the agency's own posted order. That version postdates Gillis' shooting, and the policy that governed the incident at the time was not available in the record. The current policy also assigns JSO's Cold Case Unit to investigate any case in which an officer intentionally fires a weapon at a person, with notice required to the State Attorney's Office critical-incident team.

Jacksonville Today reported in August 2025 that criminal-justice experts had separately raised questions about the discretion built into JSO's use-of-force policy while examining an unrelated traffic-stop arrest. Jacksonville's case echoes other mental-health-crisis shootings drawing legal scrutiny elsewhere: in California, Fontana agreed to pay more than $3.2 million to the family of Jaime Valdez, an unarmed man fatally shot by an officer during a 2023 mental health crisis, with that case dismissed earlier this month after a settlement, according to the San Bernardino Sun. In Seattle, attorneys for Urban Andrew Seay's family have filed a $30 million claim against that city over his fatal police shooting, per MyNorthwest, though that matter remains a claim rather than a filed lawsuit.