Greater Birmingham/ Crime & Emergencies

Jefferson County Seeks Dismissal in Patton Park Murder Case

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
Jefferson County Seeks Dismissal in Patton Park Murder CaseN. Richard Arrington Jr. Blvd. — Office Filing Dismissal Motion
Google Street View

Jefferson County prosecutors have asked a circuit judge to dismiss the murder case against Jalynd Rashad Rayford, the 26-year-old indicted in the killing of Areyelle Yarbrough. She was 32 when gunfire at an Easter gathering at W.C. Patton Park killed her and wounded five other people.

A trial had been tentatively set for the week after November 13, 2026, AL.com reported, and the dismissal request was filed Friday. ABC 33/40 reported that the Jefferson County District Attorney's Office submitted the motion on behalf of District Attorney Danny Carr. It asks the court to dismiss case CC 2024-4195 without prejudice, states no reason, and does not show whether a judge has ruled.

A Motion The Filing Does Not Explain

Dismissal without prejudice would end this prosecution without barring the state from bringing the charge again. That is the relief the request puts before a judge. The motion, as ABC 33/40 described it, does not say why prosecutors filed it, and it does not show a ruling.

Rayford was charged in Yarbrough's death only. AL.com reported in August 2024 that he was not charged in the shootings that injured the other five people, and that investigators were still searching for those responsible. The five who were wounded were ages 5 to 21.

Ontario Tillman and Adam Parker have represented Rayford. Parker said Rayford maintained his innocence, and said forensic evidence did not match him. In September 2024, prosecutors filed a motion to revoke his bond.

Hundreds Gathered For Easter

The gunfire erupted just after 7 p.m. on April 4, 2021, at W.C. Patton Park in Birmingham. Hundreds of people, if not more, had gathered to celebrate Easter.

A witness said two women were sitting on a blue Dodge Charger when someone opened fire, striking the car and both women. The witness said one of them was shot in the chest and that the other was Yarbrough. She was killed. Five others were wounded.

Birmingham Police Chief Scott Thurmond said investigators believed members of H2K, a Birmingham street gang also known as Hard to Kill, were behind the dozens of bullets fired in the park that day. AL.com reported that belief with its account of the August 2024 indictment. The grand jury charged Rayford in Yarbrough's murder, not in the wounds to the other five.

Two Years, Then An Arrest In Georgia

The killing remained unsolved for two years. In April 2023, the FBI and the Birmingham Police Department announced a $30,000 reward for information leading to Yarbrough's killer or killers.

Police announced Rayford's arrest in 2023. He was taken into custody that September in Georgia. A Jefferson County grand jury indicted him for murder in August 2024, more than three years after the Easter shooting.

The same grand jury indicted him for an unrelated robbery of a woman, committed several weeks after the shooting at the park. AL.com reported that he is awaiting trial on the robbery charge. Friday's motion seeks dismissal of the murder case, CC 2024-4195.

Other Charges, Still Separate

Rayford was also charged in a later shooting that wounded a 12-year-old during an alleged domestic incident with his girlfriend. Those charges were bound over to a grand jury for consideration of an indictment, a step that sends a case upward for that decision. They are not the prosecution in Friday's motion.

The park injuries have remained a separate line in the public record. As of the August 2024 indictment, Rayford had not been charged in them, and investigators were still searching for who shot those five people.

Areyelle Yarbrough

Yarbrough had graduated from Alabama A&M University and was working toward an MBA. She was a manager over 12 employees at the Jefferson County Department of Revenue, where she headed principal accounting for business and sales tax licensing. Both of her parents have died.

The murder charge now waits on a judge. The robbery charge, AL.com reported, was still awaiting trial. In the August 2024 account, the search for whoever wounded the others at Patton Park was still open.