
A Bakersfield judge has denied Carter and Bryce Hanson's request to play football for Garces Memorial High School against Bakersfield Christian on Friday, ruling that the brothers failed to show the California Interscholastic Federation violated its own rules when it suspended them for the season. The decision keeps both players sidelined as their eligibility dispute heads toward a hearing scheduled for Jan. 15, 2027.
Judge Thomas S. Clark issued the ruling Friday, writing that it is not necessary for the court to determine whether CIF's conclusions are factually correct in order to find that the organization followed its member-adopted rules without acting arbitrarily or capriciously, according to KGET. CIF, which governs high school sports across California, had initially granted the Hanson brothers full eligibility in August after their transfer from Liberty, and both played in the Rams' first five games before being ruled ineligible. CIF Central Section reversed course in early October, citing a failure by the brothers to make a valid change of residence. Garces Memorial High School itself is not a party to the case.
Family Says It Never Got a Fair Hearing
The Hansons dispute CIF's residence finding, and their attorneys say they still have not received a real explanation for the suspension. Despite weeks of trying, the family's legal team said they got nothing beyond two sentences in a letter. Attorney Mark Amador, of the San Diego-based firm Wingert Grebing Brubaker & Walshok, said the Hansons were never given an opportunity to present their side. He also said the family has still not seen the full 57-page private-investigator report that reportedly flagged potential use of a false address of record.
CIF's attorney, Ronald J. Scholar, pushed back hard on the family's account in court. He said the investigation found the brothers leaving a house not listed as their current residence at 7:45 a.m. while heading to school, and argued that the brothers were in fact staying at that house. CIF rules require that a prior residence be completely abandoned for a transfer to be valid. Scholar also argued the family's own conduct undercut its urgency, noting they waited 38 days to file a petition and another 10 days to seek the temporary restraining order before Friday's game.
Recruiting Stakes and a January Hearing Ahead
Attorney William T. Zimmer, representing the Hanson family, told the court the stakes go well beyond one football game. He argued CIF's decision has caused irreparable harm and could cost the Hansons hundreds of thousands of dollars in NIL money. Carter Hanson, a junior, is ranked among the state's top running backs for the class of 2028, and Zimmer said his suspension meant no new game tape was generated for review by scouts at Division I programs, naming UCLA, Texas A&M and Florida State as schools whose scouts could not evaluate fresh footage. Zimmer said some programs have since backed off.
Bryce Hanson, a senior defensive back who has verbally committed to Southern Utah's football program, has also paid a price, according to his family's attorney. Zimmer said Bryce lost out on opportunities at two schools because he couldn't take the field this season. Zimmer described the case as one touching on the boys' livelihoods, potential livelihoods and futures, and said it has been difficult to prepare given how much is at stake. Judge Clark has set a Jan. 15 hearing at which CIF's counsel must explain why a preliminary injunction should not be granted while the underlying case continues.
Part of a Statewide Surge in Transfers
The Hansons' case lands amid a broader spike in California high school transfers that has strained CIF's rules statewide. The organization recorded 17,618 transfers across its 10 sections in the 2025-26 school year, a new record, according to the Los Angeles Times. That figure first topped 17,000 in 2023-24, when the state saw 17,068 transfers, and the Southern Section alone logged 7,248 transfers last year, also a record for that section. CIF held a roundtable in 2025 to weigh possible changes to its transfer policy, but those discussions have stayed on hold while a separate court case plays out.
That other case involves former high school football player Dominik Calhoun, whose lawsuit challenging CIF's rules on transfers and NIL was dismissed for a second time in Northern California federal court, the Los Angeles Times reported. While that suit was pending, CIF had paused consideration of changes to several policies, including transfers. For now, the Hanson brothers remain unable to suit up for Garces as their own fight over residency, eligibility and lost opportunity heads toward a January courtroom date.









