Houston/ Crime & Emergencies

Katy Personal Banker Stops 75-Year-Old From Losing $42,000 in Second Scam Hit

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Katy Personal Banker Stops 75-Year-Old From Losing $42,000 in Second Scam HitFifth Third Bank — Approximate Site Of $42,000 Scam Intervention
Google Street View

Ted Bittner, 75, walked into a Katy bank asking to withdraw $42,000 in cash, just one day after phone scammers had already talked him out of $30,000. A personal banker noticed something was wrong, got on the phone with the callers herself, and stopped him from losing a second, far larger sum.

According to FOX 26 Houston, the callers had posed as federal agents and told Bittner that someone had used his bank account to buy a computer, claiming they needed cash from him to help bring the culprits to justice. Bittner went to the Fifth Third Bank branch at 810 South Mason Road in Katy and walked up to the teller line to request the $42,000, unaware he was about to be scammed a second time in as many days.

A Banker Steps In Before the Money Moves

That's when personal banker Nyesha Wingate intervened, according to the station's report. She got the scammers on speakerphone and confronted them directly. The scammer hung up, and Wingate then helped Bittner block the number on his phone, cutting off the contact before any more money could change hands.

The encounter reportedly led to a lasting friendship between Bittner and Wingate, per the same account. It's a small, human coda to a scam built entirely on fear and urgency — pressure the callers used to try to get Bittner to hand over cash.

Part of a Statewide and National Surge

The scale of the problem extends well beyond one Katy bank lobby. Texans aged 60 and older reported $678.6 million in scam losses in 2025, the third-highest total in the nation, according to FOX 26 Houston, which cited the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center. The same report noted that bank impersonation scams nearly tripled between 2024 and 2025. Bittner's callers, by contrast, posed as federal agents rather than bank representatives.

The pattern also appeared elsewhere in Texas about a year earlier. In Montgomery County, a resident reportedly got a call from someone posing as an FDIC investigator on December 10, 2025, and was instructed to send $30,000 for supposed safekeeping, according to WoodlandsOnline. The following day, the suspect reportedly called again demanding another $30,000, though authorities later recovered the first payment and returned it to the victim, per that outlet's report.

A separate case in Bexar County involved an alleged online investment scam in which a man reportedly collected $30,000 in cash from an elderly person on October 3. KSAT reported that the suspect arrived in a gray vehicle at a residence in northwest Bexar County and collected the money under false pretenses, according to the Bexar County Sheriff's Office.

Other Bank Employees Have Caught Scams Too

Bank staff intervening at the teller line has become a recurring storyline nationally. In Parma Heights, Ohio, Fifth Third Bank employees Angela Moulagiannis and Michael Pokorny stepped in when a 70-year-old woman brought in a $150,000 check connected to a scam, according to News 5 Cleveland. In that case, the woman reportedly believed a friend had recommended she buy property in Thailand and had been persuaded to bring the check to the bank.

Federal regulators have been tracking a similar trajectory for years. The Federal Trade Commission has reported that reports from older adults who lost $10,000 or more to scams increased more than fourfold between 2020 and 2024, and that older adults' aggregate reported fraud losses rose from about $600 million in 2020 to $2.4 billion in 2024. Those figures underscore why a single teller-line intervention, like the one that protected Bittner's $42,000, has become such a meaningful line of defense against fraud targeting seniors.