
A King William County sheriff's deputy stopped John Conrad Schlough for suspected impaired driving and let him go — about an hour before Schlough drove the wrong way on Route 360 and killed 39-year-old Mike Jones in a head-on crash. Now Jones's widow wants to know why her husband's death wasn't prevented.
Schlough was convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Jones's February 27, 2025 death and was sentenced to 20 years in prison, with seven years suspended, according to WTVR. Before the fatal crash, Deputy Tyler Anthony stopped Schlough on Route 30, roughly 12 miles from where the collision would later happen, after an off-duty law enforcement officer called 911 to report that Schlough's truck was weaving, tailgating, and possibly being driven by someone intoxicated. The computer-aided dispatch report from that call described the driver as “all over the roadway,” “possibly intoxicated” and “tailgating” the caller, per the same outlet's report. Anthony reported no signs of impairment and released Schlough.
No Body Camera Footage From the First Stop
The King William County Sheriff's Office said no body-worn camera footage exists from that initial stop because Anthony's camera never activated — a failure the office itself described as a “policy failure.” The sheriff's office said Motorola confirmed no data was created or deleted in connection with the stop, addressing any suggestion that footage once existed and was erased.
Sheriff Lumpkin requested an internal case review, which the sheriff's office says it completed on March 17, 2025. That review concluded Anthony was not derelict in his duties and that the stop was conducted consistent with departmental policy and training — even though the camera failed to record it. The office also said in a written statement that it was plausible Schlough consumed alcohol after his encounter with Anthony, before the fatal crash occurred.
Roughly an hour after Anthony let him go, Schlough was driving the wrong way on Route 360 when he struck Jones's car head-on in King William County, near Commerce Park Drive, just before 10:30 p.m. that Thursday, according to WRIC. The crash caused Jones's car to catch fire, and he died at the scene. A preliminary breath test taken afterward showed Schlough's blood alcohol content was .172 — more than double the legal limit in Virginia, per a preliminary test cited by the station's report. Law enforcement officers at the scene also noted they could smell alcohol on Schlough, and Anthony recognized Schlough's truck when he arrived at the crash site.
A Husband, Father, and 49ers Fan
Mike Jones was Christy Jones's husband of almost two decades and the father of their two sons. He was a car club enthusiast and a San Francisco 49ers fan who had survived a double bypass surgery years earlier and was on disability after surviving a massive heart attack at age 32, working for DoorDash on the side for extra income. “My feeling is my husband would still be here if the police officer had done his job,” Christy Jones said, according to the station's account. She has said she believes her husband's death could have been prevented, and she described Mike as someone who loved his family.
A 911 caller reported a pickup truck traveling the wrong way on Route 360 about one minute before the collision, then reported that two vehicles had collided and that the truck might explode.
Sheriff's Office Response and Lingering Questions
The sheriff's office said it worked with the commonwealth's attorney's office to assist in Schlough's prosecution and said it has taken measures to improve training, though it stated those changes were not necessarily tied to this specific incident. The office said it could not disclose specific disciplinary action because the matter involved personnel.
Body-camera activation failures are not unique to Virginia. A separate investigation by the Utah Investigative Journalism Project, based on nearly 170 records requests to 48 law enforcement agencies in that state, found that officers received formal reprimands in most cases involving body-camera policy violations. That review identified 25 officers across 11 agencies with such violations between January 2019 and June 2025, including one Unified police officer who failed to activate his camera 103 times in the first three months of 2023 alone. Those findings reflect practices in Utah and do not establish how Virginia departments typically handle similar violations.
For Christy Jones, the unanswered question remains why the deputy who stopped her husband's killer less than an hour before the crash let him drive away. The internal review found no fault with Anthony's conduct, but the absence of body-camera footage means there is no recording of what he observed — or didn't — during that roadside stop on Route 30.









