
A kosher spinoff of the popular Brooklyn Square Pizza chain is reportedly plotting a second location in Toms River, aiming to take over the space currently occupied by La Mossa Pizzeria along Route 9. The move would bring Kosher Square Pizza beyond its original Oakhurst storefront, which opened in June, into a corridor that has seen explosive residential growth over the past decade.
According to YeahThatsKosher, Kosher Square Pizza is opening a second location at The Row in Toms River, with plans to replace La Mossa Pizzeria and absorb the adjacent space formerly occupied by Miele Artisanal Gelateria. The planned address is 2170 Lakewood Road, and the site would reportedly include a companion concept called Milano Cafe & Gelato in the former Miele footprint, according to the same outlet.
Owner David Mizrachi told the outlet he hoped the Toms River shop would open within a couple of weeks of the report, though that was described as an expectation rather than a confirmed date. Unlike the Oakhurst original, the Toms River location is planned to have more room and additional ovens, which would allow it to sell pizza by the slice, an option not currently available at the first store, the report notes.
A Dairy Kitchen Built On Brooklyn Square's Recipes
Kosher Square Pizza serves Brooklyn Square recipes under kosher supervision, giving Jersey Shore customers a dairy version of the square pies that built the original chain's reputation. The Oakhurst location is a dairy restaurant that is chalav yisroel and pas yisroel, and it is kosher certified by the Jersey Shore Orthodox Rabbinate, per YeahThatsKosher's reporting. The menu there includes upside-down squares, vodka pizza, a spinach and artichoke square, a pie called the Johnny Pepe, round pies, calzones, pasta and fish entrées.
The planned Milano Cafe & Gelato next door is expected to make chalav Yisrael gelato and parve gelato in house, alongside espresso, drinks, pastries, desserts and focaccia sandwiches, according to the same report. Sourcing on the partnership's spelling varies: YeahThatsKosher refers to the owner as David Mizrachi, while PMQ Pizza spells it David Mizrahi in describing a partnership between Peter Grippo and the veteran restaurateur. PMQ also reported that Brooklyn Square Pizza already had six stores in New Jersey by the time the Oakhurst kosher offshoot opened on June 7.
From Dave Portnoy's 8.9 Score To A Kosher Pivot
Brooklyn Square built its name well before the kosher spinoff came along. Dave Portnoy gave the chain's square pie an 8.9 score after a visit to its Jackson flagship in 2020, telling the camera, per PMQ, “This is spectacular. It's a great pizza,” and later calling it “the best square slice maybe we've done in these reviews.”
As Shore News Network reports, Peter Grippo has owned pizzerias since 2001 and started making pizza at age 16. He grew up in Gravesend, Brooklyn, the son of Italian immigrants from Caggiano in the Campania region, and he co-owns Brooklyn Square with his wife, Susan Grippo. The outlet notes Good Morning America named Brooklyn Square the best pizzeria in the country, while the Star-Ledger called it the best in New Jersey. Grippo has also dealt with health challenges, having lived with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma since 2016 — the same disease that killed his father at age 52 — and Shore News Network reports that both Grippo and Mizrahi are now in remission.
Why Toms River Makes Sense For The Expansion
The push into Toms River tracks with years of rapid population growth across Ocean County. Toms River added 4,199 residents between 2010 and 2020, according to the Ocean County Census 2020 Redistricting Data Release. Countywide, Ocean County grew by 10.5%, adding 60,662 residents over that span — the second-highest growth rate in the state, per the same county summary. Neighboring Lakewood saw the largest jump of any town in the county's figures, adding 42,315 residents in that same decade.
Kosher Square Pizza isn't the only kosher concept that has eyed a Toms River storefront in recent years. Back in November 2024, YeahThatsKosher reported that Bravo Kosher Pizza's ownership confirmed plans to open a location at 1012 Cox Cro Road in Toms River that December, with supervision likely falling to the local Vaad, KCL — though that report did not establish whether the restaurant ultimately opened. Whether Kosher Square Pizza's Toms River plans play out on the timeline David Mizrachi described remains to be seen.









