
A Los Angeles nonprofit law firm has sued the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to stop a new rule that would require every person living in federally funded public housing to prove qualifying immigration status just to stay in their home. The lawsuit, filed on behalf of three people currently living in Los Angeles public housing, aims to block a regulation set to take effect Dec. 14 that would upend a decades-long policy allowing family members with different immigration statuses to live under the same roof.
Public Counsel filed the suit in federal court late Monday night, according to the Los Angeles Times. The firm's lawyers argue HUD lacks the authority to make this kind of change on its own; that power, they argue, lies with Congress, which originally enacted the rule allowing mixed-status families to live together in public housing or voucher-funded units. Public Counsel is described as an L.A.-based nonprofit law firm, and the case is one piece of a broader fight over a regulation HUD first floated in 2019.
Among the plaintiffs is a 24-year-old identified only as J.L., who has lived in the same apartment run by the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles for 15 years. She shares the three-bedroom unit, for which her family pays $2,700 a month, with her two brothers, her mother and her stepfather. J.L. and her siblings are U.S. citizens; her parents are undocumented, according to the same report.
A Family Already Living in Fear
J.L. works as a pharmacy technician and told the Los Angeles Times that the prospect of family separation has brought constant stress and anxiety, since her household could suddenly lose its home. Her family has been afraid to leave the house amid a reported increase in immigration enforcement activity in California. J.L. said her parents rely on her for translation at doctors' appointments and while grocery shopping — an everyday reliance that underscores what's at stake if the rule forces the family apart.
Under the new rule, undocumented immigrants and DACA recipients would not qualify for federally funded rent subsidies, and family members without qualifying status would not receive the federal rental subsidy either. HUD has said that residents without qualifying immigration status have no right to live in publicly funded housing. Public housing households already must prove income to qualify, including when some members are ineligible for rental discounts, and those households pay prorated monthly rents that are generally higher when certain family members don't qualify for subsidy.
The Numbers Behind the Policy Fight
HUD estimated that in 2024, 79,300 members of mixed-status families lived in public housing across the country, including 7,190 households in California. Citing data from the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, the Los Angeles Times reported that 1,709 mixed-status families are currently benefiting from public housing assistance in the city, and that HACLA also reported 7,700 mixed-status family members living in Los Angeles public housing. A separate account, from MyNewsLA, cited HACLA estimates of roughly 1,700 mixed-status families representing an estimated 7,500 Angelenos who could be affected — a figure that doesn't exactly match the Times' count, underscoring how unsettled the local impact estimates remain. HACLA, which serves more than 67,000 households, is the largest low-income housing provider in Los Angeles.
HUD's own analysis found that the number of mixed-status families in public housing has declined over the years, and the agency theorized that some families left after the rule was first proposed in 2019. The agency anticipates that fear of family separation would again prompt the departure of most mixed families once the new rule takes effect, and it wrote that the primary effect would be to assist proportionally fewer households and household members, but with higher subsidies per remaining household. HUD Secretary Scott Turner has said the administration intends to end what he described as exploitation of government-funded welfare programs by illegal aliens and ineligible noncitizens, per the Times report.
City Council Weighs In Before the Deadline
Five Los Angeles City Council members introduced a resolution Friday criticizing the Trump administration's rule and calling for a coordinated city response to protect affected residents, MyNewsLA reported. That resolution had not yet gone to a vote as of the November report and is expected to come before the full council at a future meeting. Spectrum News 1 also reported that the council unanimously passed an emergency resolution opposing the proposed rule during the public-comment period, which ended April 21.
HUD had tried to revise the longstanding policy once before, withdrawing a 2019 proposal in 2021, before reintroducing the rule change in February 2026 — a move that drew more than 11,000 public comments in opposition, per MyNewsLA's reporting. The nonpartisan Center on Budget and Policy Priorities has estimated that about 25,000 families nationwide could be affected, nearly half of them children, with 96% of potentially affected people identified as people of color and 86% as Latino, according to Spectrum News 1. That outlet also described another resident, identified as Maria, who has raised her five children at Mar Vista Gardens for more than 14 years and shares similar worries about the rule.
Public Counsel's lawyers have warned that forcing mixed-status families out of public housing could worsen the region's affordable housing crisis rather than ease it. Amanda Mangaser Savage, an attorney with the firm, said displaced families could increase demand for shelters and other services, straining resources that other low-income residents also depend on. HACLA has said it is reviewing the final regulation and assessing its applicability, operational requirements and compliance timelines, adding that it will pursue all available avenues as the Dec. 14 deadline approaches.









