Tampa/ Crime & Emergencies

Lake Worth Beach Starbucks Shooter Convicted of Manslaughter, Not Murder

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Lake Worth Beach Starbucks Shooter Convicted of Manslaughter, Not MurderSource: Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office

A jury has found Justin Ray Boersma guilty of manslaughter, not murder, in the 2021 shooting death of Samuel Joseph Rossetti outside a Lake Worth Beach Starbucks drive-thru — a verdict that closes out more than five years of legal limbo over whether the killing was a crime of rage or an act of self-defense.

The shooting happened around noon on April 28, 2021, near a Starbucks in the 100 block of North Dixie Highway, according to WPTV. Rossetti, 31, was shot during an argument at the drive-thru with Boersma, who was 19 at the time, according to WPEC. A jury has now found Boersma guilty of manslaughter rather than the first-degree murder charge he originally faced.

What Witnesses and the Arrest Report Described

Witnesses told investigators that Boersma had cut in front of Rossetti's truck while the two were waiting in the drive-thru line, the same WPTV report notes. According to the arrest report cited by the Sun Sentinel, Rossetti got out of his pickup truck and approached Boersma's vehicle, banging on the driver's side window and ripping the door handle off.

The arrest report goes on to say that Boersma armed himself with a gun, got out of his car, and fired three shots as Rossetti was walking back toward his truck. Boersma told detectives afterward that he acted in self-defense, though the same report notes he admitted he never saw a weapon on Rossetti. He left the scene and later turned himself in, per an earlier account from the station.

From Murder Charge to Manslaughter Verdict

Boersma was initially charged with first-degree murder and was held in the Palm Beach County Jail without bond while the case moved through the system, per the earlier WPEC report on the case. A defense attorney interviewed by the outlet at the time said Rossetti's approach to the vehicle could support a self-defense argument, a theory that appears to have resonated in some form with jurors who ultimately rejected the murder charge in favor of the lesser count.

The distinction matters enormously for Boersma's future. A first-degree murder conviction in Florida can carry a life sentence, while manslaughter carries a far shorter maximum penalty — the difference between the two charges essentially came down to whether jurors believed Boersma was defending himself or reacting with unlawful violence in the heat of a parking-lot confrontation.

The Father Who Wrote About Breaking Cycles

Away from the courtroom, Rossetti's family has spent the years since his death keeping his memory alive. Rossetti wrote a children's book titled When My Dad Fell Through the Moon, which deals with helping children understand that a parent's addiction is never their fault, according to the same WPEC report. His family has said he left behind a foster son.

Separately, WGXA reported that loved ones described the book as addressing dealing with an addict parent and teaching children that it is never their fault, framing Rossetti's writing as part of a broader mission his family has continued since his death.

Tampa-Crime & Emergencies