
A vacant lot that has sat untouched in Lexington's Hamburg area for more than two decades could be developed for apartments after the Lexington-Fayette Urban County Council voted 12 to 1 on Tuesday, Nov. 17, to approve a zone change needed to allow 99 apartment units off Sir Barton Way. The vote came despite a petition signed by 166 local residents and a legal challenge from a lawyer representing some of their nearest neighbors.
The development, proposed by RAK Properties, calls for two two-story buildings and three three-story buildings spread across roughly 4.7 acres at 2501 Sir Barton Way, according to the Lexington Herald-Leader. The property sits adjacent to the Whitaker Family YMCA and the Tuscany subdivision, with a creek running through its back, and it has had no direct frontage on Sir Barton Way itself. The outlet reports the site has been zoned for professional use since 2001 and has simply never been developed, though its prior professional zoning would have allowed short-term rentals on the first floor and apartments on the upper floors. Separately, WKYT reports the land has been vacant since 2002 and that R-A-K Properties Lexington and MMK Ventures LLC own the property, after Retina Associates of Kentucky bought it in 2021 for an expansion that never happened.
A Contested Path Through Two Votes
Tuesday's council vote followed a bumpy road through the city's planning process. The Urban County Planning Commission deadlocked 4 to 4 on the zone change on July 23, then approved it on a 7-2 vote at its August meeting, per the Herald-Leader's reporting. Dick Murphy, a lawyer for RAK Properties and the developers, said during the July meeting that he waived the 30-day requirement typically governing how quickly a tied vote can be revisited, and he said there was no objection at the time to setting the August meeting date.
That timeline became a point of legal dispute. Jessica Winters, a lawyer representing some Tuscany residents, argued the planning commission erred by revisiting the zone change in August and contended the vote was not legally valid, noting that state law allows the commission 30 days to revisit a tied zone change while the commission in this case waited 35 days before approving it, the paper notes.
Neighbors Raise Access and Safety Concerns
City planners themselves opposed approval of the zone change, raising concerns about the single road leading into the property and saying the development's location was not pedestrian friendly, according to the same report. The proposed complex's only entrance sits between two banks, and that access road is not a public road. Winters said the access was unsafe and presented a public safety question.
Karen Hendren, who lives adjacent to the proposed apartments, said the development would be visible from her property and that its lighting would affect Tuscany residents. Beyond Winters's legal argument, the Herald-Leader describes residents raising broader concerns about public safety, property values, traffic and light pollution tied to the project.
A Councilwoman Frames the Debate as Economic
Councilwoman Emma Curtis voted for the zone change, but she pushed back on some of the opposition, saying that certain neighbors' complaints were not based on actual effects on Tuscany residents and that some objections boiled down to the apartments simply being built in neighbors' backyards. Curtis said the debate ultimately concerned class and access to housing in certain parts of the city, pointing out that homes in Tuscany sell for more than $500,000 while one-bedroom apartments in the area rent for more than $2,200 a month.
Lisa Higgins-Hord, who represents the 6th council district that includes Hamburg, cast the lone vote against the zone change. Murphy, for his part, described the vacant parcel as underutilized and argued the property could help address Lexington's housing shortage, framing RAK Properties' plan as housing for working people in what he called the missing middle.
Earlier coverage of the same proposal had described the complex as including a community center, a pool and 176 parking spaces across five residential buildings, a plan that planning staff had recommended against before the commission's own vote to approve it in August, according to the Herald-Leader's earlier reporting. With the council's zone change now approved, RAK Properties has the rezoning it needed to build apartments throughout the long-vacant site.









