
An unconscious 24-year-old woman in an angel costume was lying near the electrified third rail at the Chambers Street subway station in Lower Manhattan when two NYPD detectives jumped down to pull her to safety, with a train arriving about two minutes after they climbed back onto the platform.
Detectives Brett Devine and Carmelo Stracuzzi were working an overtime tour at the station when they heard someone yelling that a person had fallen onto the tracks, according to New York Post. The woman had fallen from the platform in what police described as an accidental fall, the outlet reported. Devine, 36, jumped onto the tracks first to reach her, while Stracuzzi, 42, stayed close behind.
A Scramble in the Dark
Devine said the platform was higher than he expected once he was down on the tracks, which he noted were about 4 feet deep, per the same account. He tapped the woman's shoulder to check whether she was conscious and asked his partner for a flashlight to help alert any approaching train operators. Moments later, the detectives heard an announcement that a train was arriving, but they weren't sure whether it was headed down the downtown local No. 1 track, where the woman lay, or the express tracks on the other side of the platform.
Stracuzzi said he saw lights at the end of the tunnel as the detectives worked to lift the woman. The two men hoisted her onto the platform together, with Devine supporting her under the arms and Stracuzzi holding her legs, the report states. Another officer helped pull the detectives back up just before the train rolled into the express track across the platform. Stracuzzi later said he wasn't sure whether that train had been rerouted away from them.
Getting Her to a Hospital
A good Samaritan helped the woman walk up the station stairs once she was off the tracks, the outlet reported. Rather than wait for an ambulance, Devine and Stracuzzi drove her to the hospital themselves in their own car, because 911 lines were tied up following Halloween festivities. Police said she was treated for minor injuries; she has only been identified as a 24-year-old woman, and her identity has not been released.
Devine, who joined the NYPD in 2012 and has four daughters ranging from 1 to 19 years old, and Stracuzzi, who joined the department in 2011 and has two daughters aged 4 and 7, were both praised for their actions. Scott Munro, president of the Detectives' Endowment Association, commended the rescue, and the association hailed the pair as heroes. A police source told the outlet that the woman's angel wings left some at the station wondering whether an angel had been watching over everyone there that night.
How Common Are These Close Calls
Platform falls like this one are not unusual in New York's transit system. A 2019 analysis of city subway incidents found that 84% occurred at station platforms, according to journals.sagepub.com. It covered 263 incidents, 185 of which involved subway-to-human interactions. Of those 263 cases, 70% involved direct train-to-pedestrian contact, the same analysis found.
Other recent rescues echo the Chambers Street scramble. In 2021, a New York City police officer and a passenger pulled a 60-year-old man to safety from Bronx subway tracks shortly before a train arrived, as reported by thehill.com. A year later, two NYPD officers rescued a 25-year-old woman who fell onto tracks at Brooklyn's Bay Ridge-95th Street station, taking her to a hospital in stable condition with a head injury, according to patch.com. In a separate case, two NYPD officers pulled a 36-year-old man off Brooklyn's southbound C train tracks after he suffered a medical episode, lifting him back onto the platform just before a train arrived, per newsnationnow.com.









