Detroit/ Crime & Emergencies

Lucas County Clears 5 Men in 1992 Killing, Opens Door to $10.2M

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Lucas County Clears 5 Men in 1992 Killing, Opens Door to $10.2MSource: Joel Rossol / Wikimedia Commons

A Lucas County court has declared five men wrongfully imprisoned in connection with the 1992 killing of Vernon Huggins, a ruling that marks the first of its kind in the county's history and opens the door to more than $10 million in compensation. Some of the men spent nearly three decades behind bars before their convictions were dismissed.

According to 13abc.com, the five men were convicted in Huggins's 1992 death, and their cases were later dismissed. The outlet called it the first time such a declaration has happened in Lucas County. Brothers Ismael and Lorenzo Vasquez were among those declared wrongfully imprisoned by Judge Ian English, while Louis Costilla Jr., Eric Misch and Joseph Rickard were also named wrongfully imprisoned in records filed on Nov. 16, per the same outlet's reporting.

A $10.2 Million Settlement, Still Pending Approval

Court documents reviewed by the station show the state of Ohio has agreed to proposed settlements totaling $10.2 million for the five men — $750,000 each for the Vasquez brothers, and $2.9 million each for Costilla, Misch and Rickard. Those settlements still need approvals before they become final, the station's report notes.

A wrongful-imprisonment determination like the one issued in Lucas County is only the first of two steps required under Ohio law before a person can collect compensation. Per the Innocence Project, the process begins with a wrongful imprisonment determination in a court of common pleas, after which the individual must file a separate civil claim in the Ohio Court of Claims.

Advocate Points to a High Bar and Other Unresolved Cases

Kay Anderson of the Northwest Ohio Innocence Clinic said the path to a wrongful-imprisonment designation is steep. “We're up against so many hurdles, and we have so many disappointing losses,” Anderson told the same outlet. She said prosecutors often fight these rulings even after they have already dismissed the underlying case, and she said she worries about other cases that have not received the designation, raising the question of who else might deserve to be freed.

The Lucas County case echoes a pattern seen elsewhere in Ohio. In Hamilton County, a judge formally declared death-row exoneree Derrick Jamison wrongfully imprisoned on March 5, opening the door to what the Death Penalty Information Center reported could be roughly $1 million in compensation, 41 years after his original conviction.

Thousands of Older Convictions Still Under Scrutiny

Advocates say cases like these point to a broader backlog across the state. A Marshall Project review of Ohio corrections data cited by Signal Cleveland found that more than 1,000 Cuyahoga County defendants convicted during the era of closed discovery, including Terry Ferrell, remain in Ohio prisons. Ferrell was convicted in 2003 of murder, aggravated burglary and kidnapping and sentenced to life without parole, according to the outlet.

For now, the Lucas County ruling stands as a rare and hard-won milestone for the five men tied to the Huggins case. Whether the settlements are finalized, and whether other wrongful-imprisonment claims follow, remains to be seen as advocates like Anderson continue pressing the question of who else deserves the same scrutiny.