
A long-stalled 2.5-acre parcel near The Village in Meridian is finally inching toward development after the city's Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval of two multifamily buildings with 88 units for the site, a scaled-back version of plans that have twice failed before. The site sits northeast of Eagle Road and Highway 55 at East River Valley Street, near the Mattress Firm store on the corner, and would complete the third and final phase of the Regency at River Valley apartment complex.
As reported by BoiseDev, the proposed development would sit roughly 150 feet from Eagle Road and East River Valley Street, according to a staff presentation. Commissioners raised concerns about site access, noise and amenities before voting to recommend approval, with several conditions modified or removed at the applicant's request. The application, from developer Bach Homes, seeks to modify existing development agreements and a conditional use permit, and still needs a final decision from Meridian City Council.
A Site That's Tried and Failed Twice Before
Bach Homes, which developed the original Regency at River Valley complex, has changed its plans twice after analyzing market conditions, per the BoiseDev report. In 2021, Meridian City Council denied a five-story, 134-unit apartment proposal with podium parking for the same phase-three site, citing a lack of access to parcels north of the property, along with traffic, parking, circulation and timing concerns, according to the staff report cited in that reporting. A year later, in 2022, the council denied a scaled-down five-story, 128-unit version with podium parking, this time pointing to traffic circulation concerns and the applicant's failure to show the project would better serve the area than previously approved storage units.
The site's original development agreement had called for self-storage units on the northern portion of the parcel and either a retail building or a drive-thru restaurant to the south. But a market analysis found an oversaturation of storage units across Idaho and projected the market would not absorb a 2023-2025 surplus until late 2026 or early 2027, prompting the proposal to expand apartments in phase three instead of building commercial space, per the staff report. Regency at River Valley's existing phases one and two sit just east of the phase-three site.
The proposal comes amid rapid city growth: Census Bureau estimates put Meridian at 142,988 residents in July 2025, up 21.4% from its 2020 population-estimate base of 117,810, the bureau’s latest city figures. That growth helps frame the site’s shift from planned storage and retail to apartments, though citywide population totals do not establish demand for this particular project or resolve concerns about traffic, access and how the building fits beside nearby businesses.
Noise, Fencing and Open Space Dominate Debate
Much of the commission's discussion centered on how to buffer residents from the adjacent state highway. Staff outlined concerns about pedestrian access to Eagle Road, noise, and the proximity of homes to the roadway, warning in the staff report that high-density housing beside a state highway raises quality-of-life and health concerns tied to vehicle emissions and noise. Staff had called for a 10-foot berm and wall along Eagle Road with a landscaping buffer, but also acknowledged that combination likely would not fully screen a four-story building.
Bach Homes pushed back on several of the proposed conditions. The developer requested alternative compliance using noise-abatement materials on the building itself paired with a 6-to-8-foot precast fence instead of the berm. Cedar Jordan, who represented Bach Homes before the commission, said the building itself would abate some noise and that the company preferred a wall closer to six feet, arguing a 6-to-8-foot wall without the berm would meet the applicant's needs.
Staff had also requested a gap in the Eagle Road-side fence to let pedestrians reach the road, but Bach Homes asked to remove that gap, arguing it could allow more roadway noise through. Commissioners ultimately indicated the applicant could omit the pathway to Eagle Road altogether. On open space, staff had proposed a common grassy gathering area of at least 5,000 square feet, which Bach Homes asked to drop, saying residents could use amenities elsewhere in the broader complex - which already includes 12,000 square feet of lawn and outdoor grilling areas.
The highway-buffer debate also touches a distinction between transportation rules and local land-use decisions. Idaho Transportation Department says noise studies for its transportation projects must follow federal requirements and state guidelines; the Federal Highway Administration’s noise policy addresses highway-project impacts and does not prescribe the materials used for noise barriers. Those rules provide context for highway noise mitigation, but the berm, fence and building-material conditions on this apartment proposal are being weighed through Meridian’s planning process.
Commissioners Split Over Fit and Fairness
Commissioner Matthew Stoll said the parcel is awkward and that the applicant has repeatedly tried to improve its proposal across multiple attempts. Commissioner Jared Smith supported the project but pressed for more sound mitigation, saying further sound reduction is sensible given the site's proximity to Eagle Road and that every decibel matters, particularly for residents who would live on the third floor.
Commissioner Maria Lorcher cast the lone vote against the commission's recommendation. She argued the four-story apartments would be too aggressive placed beside a one-story retail building and in front of a three-story building, and said the applicant resisted conditions by repeatedly seeking to remove, modify or strike them. The commission, which currently has one vacant seat, recommended approval with several conditions altered or dropped at Bach Homes' request despite Lorcher's opposition.
The application now heads to Meridian City Council for a final decision, the body that rejected two earlier, larger versions of this same project in 2021 and 2022. Whether the smaller 88-unit footprint and the compromise on fencing and noise abatement will be enough to satisfy council members remains to be seen.
The council hearing is now scheduled for Dec. 8, according to the city’s public-hearing notice, which lists the application as a request for two multifamily buildings with 88 units. The parking request has also changed since the commission review: Bach Homes asked to withdraw its request for reduced parking on Sept. 9, saying a revised plan meets the city’s parking requirements, as shown in the application timeline.









