New York City/ Crime & Emergencies

Merrick Mall Stop and Shop Robbed, Employee Threatened With Knife

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Merrick Mall Stop and Shop Robbed, Employee Threatened With KnifeStop and Shop — Site Of November 2026 Robbery
Google Street View

A man walked into the Stop and Shop convenience store at Merrick Mall early Monday morning, loaded up a duffel bag with items pulled straight from the freezer, and threatened to stab an employee who tried to stop him before running off toward Hewlett Avenue, according to police.

The incident unfolded around 6:45 a.m. Monday, according to Daily Voice, which reported that the man filled his bag with frozen goods before a 29-year-old male employee attempted to intervene. That's when the suspect threatened to stab the worker if he was touched, per the outlet's reporting on the Nassau County Police Department's account of the robbery.

Investigators said the man then fled on foot toward Hewlett Avenue, leaving the store with the stolen freezer items still in his duffel bag. It's unclear whether the employee suffered any injuries during the confrontation, and police have not said whether anyone has been identified or arrested in connection with the theft.

What Police Say the Suspect Looked Like

Police described the suspect as a thin white male standing 5 feet 10 inches tall and weighing around 200 pounds. He was last seen wearing a black hooded sweatshirt, black pants, a black New York Knicks cap, and a watch on his left wrist, according to the same report. Nassau County Crime Stoppers is asking anyone with information to call 1-800-244-TIPS.

A String of Knifepoint Robberies Across Long Island

The Merrick Mall incident comes amid a run of separate knifepoint robberies reported elsewhere on Long Island, though nothing in the available evidence ties those cases to the Stop and Shop theft. According to CBS News, Suffolk County police said a man armed with a knife walked into The Barn on Belmont Avenue in West Babylon around 1:48 p.m. Tuesday and demanded cash before fleeing with an undisclosed amount of money.

That same day, Nassau County police said a man armed with a large kitchen knife held up two employees at a Game Stop on Sunrise Highway in Merrick just before 9 p.m., the network reported. Investigators believe the suspect in both Tuesday robberies is the same man, who they say has been targeting stores throughout Suffolk and Nassau counties. The suspected series now includes four robberies in Suffolk County, seven in Nassau County and one attempt, with crimes dating back to February 13, according to the same CBS News report.

Merrick has seen armed robberies before. In November 2015, two male suspects armed with handguns robbed the Five Guys at 2099 Merrick Road, striking a 25-year-old employee in the head and fleeing with an undisclosed amount of cash, according to a report from Long Island Exchange. That employee was treated for minor injuries at the time.

For now, Monday's Stop and Shop robbery remains its own open case, with Nassau police continuing to seek the public's help identifying the man in the Knicks cap who threatened an employee over a bag of frozen groceries.