Columbus/ Crime & Emergencies

Mifflin Township Disbands Police After Third Levy Failure, 65 Years Ends

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 11, 2026
Mifflin Township Disbands Police After Third Levy Failure, 65 Years EndsFranklin County Sheriff's Office — Possible Township Call Responder
Google Street View

Mifflin Township trustees voted to disband the township's police department, shutting it down immediately after voters rejected a police funding levy for the third time. The department had served the unincorporated Franklin County community for 65 years, and its closure leaves officials scrambling to figure out how to respond to the nearly 6,000 calls for help the township receives every year.

Trustees cited three failed levies in reaching their decision, according to 10TV. The most recent attempt, Issue 45 on the 2026 Franklin County ballot, asked voters for an additional 6.96-mill levy to fund police coverage in the township's unincorporated area, an ongoing measure that would have cost property owners $244 for every $100,000 of county auditor market value, according to the Columbus Dispatch. A previously failed levy would have provided roughly $1 million for 24/7 police coverage, per a report from ABC 6.

Mifflin Township Trustee Kevin Cavener said citizens had made clear they did not want to keep the police department, even as he expressed sadness over the closure. “All the options are on the table and we're just not sure what they are,” Cavener told ABC 6, adding that officials did not yet know what would best serve residents of unincorporated Mifflin Township.

A Department Already Stretched Thin

The vote caps months of turmoil inside the department. The force typically employed six full-time officers and two part-time officers, but staffing losses had cut it down to two full-time officers before the disbandment. Earlier reporting found Mifflin Township left without regular patrols after two of its three active officers resigned, and the remaining officer was pulled off patrol because township policy requires two officers on duty to patrol, the station's report noted.

Even at full strength, the department's coverage was limited to weekdays during daytime hours, per the same account. With the department now closed, the Franklin County Sheriff's Office will respond to priority calls in the township but will not provide dedicated patrols in the area, leaving a gap that officials must now decide how to fill.

Two Mifflin Township officers were shot and seriously injured in May 2025, a reminder of the risks the department's small remaining staff faced even as its ranks thinned. Brian Steel, president of the Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge 9, called the disbandment deeply disappointing and said the department had served the community for 65 years. Steel said the FOP would support members being laid off and help them find other law-enforcement jobs, adding that the union would not abandon the officers who served the community.

What Comes Next Is Still Unclear

Trustees must meet again in the coming days to determine next steps, and officials still must determine how to cover residents' calls for help. Cavener predicted that the lack of police presence would undoubtedly bring a rise in crime, though that remains his forecast rather than a documented outcome.

Ohio law gives townships at least one path forward: Section 505.43 of the Ohio Revised Code allows a township to contract with other townships, municipal corporations, certain park districts, county sheriffs, or joint police districts to obtain police protection. The statute doesn't spell out which option Mifflin Township might pursue, and officials haven't said which arrangement, if any, they are leaning toward.

Mifflin Township isn't alone in confronting this kind of budget-driven policing crisis. In Pennsylvania, Marion Township's board recently voted to disband its part-time police department and contracted instead with neighboring New Sewickley, citing rising costs and the advantages of a full-time force, according to WPXI. And in Ohio's Whitewater Township, officials say they simply can't afford the roughly $1.2 million contract the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office has offered for dedicated patrols, a situation reported by WVXU; without a new deal, that township could lose traffic enforcement and regular patrols by January 1, 2027, though deputies would still respond to emergencies.

For now, Mifflin Township residents are left waiting as trustees weigh their limited options. No timeline has been given for when a decision on replacement coverage might be announced.