Sacramento/ Politics & Govt

Modesto Weighs Scrapping Protest Mask Ban After ACLU Lawsuit, Arrests

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Modesto Weighs Scrapping Protest Mask Ban After ACLU Lawsuit, ArrestsSource: Tony Webster / Wikimedia Commons

Modesto's controversial ban on face coverings at protests could soon be history, with the ACLU of Northern California announcing an agreement that would eliminate the rule — though city officials say the deal is not yet a done one. The dispute traces back to a June 2025 ICE Out rally, where five demonstrators were arrested simply for covering their faces, setting off a federal lawsuit over Modesto's protest public-assembly ordinance, adopted in August 2019 and nearly six years old at the time.

The ACLU of Northern California says Modesto has agreed to eliminate its ban on face coverings and bike helmets at protests and to let journalists wear personal safety gear while covering demonstrations, according to a press release from the ACLU of Northern California. But that account is disputed: the Modesto Bee reports the settlement has not actually been finalized, and that the Modesto City Council has not yet approved the proposed changes. CBS News Sacramento reported that the ban could be repealed after a federal lawsuit.

A Special Meeting and an Unanswered Question

The City Council was scheduled to take up the proposed amendments at a special meeting Monday, November 16, at 5 p.m., per the same Modesto Bee report. What happened at that meeting — whether members approved the changes or sent them back for more work — has not been reported in the available coverage.

The case began when the ACLU filed a complaint in March 2026 on behalf of three individual plaintiffs and the Pacific Media Workers Guild, naming the city of Modesto and Police Chief Brandon Gillespie as defendants, according to the organization's case page. By June 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California had issued a preliminary injunction blocking enforcement of the ordinance while the lawsuit proceeded, the same source notes.

An Ordinance That Sat Unused for Years

Modesto actually passed the face-covering ordinance back in 2019, but the city did not enforce it until the June 2025 ICE Out rally, the article notes. That's when five demonstrators were arrested for wearing face coverings — charges that were later dropped, according to the Modesto Bee's reporting. Before the proposed changes, violating the ordinance by wearing or carrying specified face coverings or safety gear was a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail, per the ACLU's press release.

The ordinance has drawn sustained public pushback at City Council meetings. A report from The Modesto Focus counted 135 instances of audience speakers denouncing the ordinance since June, compared with just 10 who defended it. The same outlet noted that Modesto's law was among only three adopted by cities in California, with Oakland and Lomita being the only others with similar bans.

What Comes Next

For now, the central facts remain unresolved in public reporting: whether the council approved the amendments at Monday's meeting, and what the settlement's final terms, approval status, and effective date will be. The ACLU has described the matter as resolved through an agreement, while the Modesto Bee has characterized it as still pending council action — a gap that leaves residents, journalists, and protesters alike waiting to see whether the ban adopted in August 2019 will be formally struck from the books.