Washington, D.C./ Politics & Govt

Montgomery County Beats DOJ Lawsuit Over Gun-Free Zones Near Parks, Churches, Schools

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 12, 2026
Montgomery County Beats DOJ Lawsuit Over Gun-Free Zones Near Parks, Churches, Schools1401 Arcola Ave — Silver Spring Neighborhood Street Scene
Google Street View

A federal judge has handed Montgomery County a win in its fight to keep guns away from parks, churches, schools, libraries and hospitals, dismissing the Justice Department's lawsuit against the county's firearm law with prejudice on Monday. The dismissal means the case, as filed, cannot be refiled in the same court — a significant setback for the federal government's effort to unwind the county's restrictions.

U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang issued the ruling, according to Bethesda Magazine, which reported that he both denied the Justice Department's request for a preliminary injunction blocking enforcement and granted the county's motion to dismiss outright. The Montgomery County law restricts firearms from thousands of places of public assembly and establishes a 100-yard exclusion zone around those locations, though it still allows people to travel on public highways that pass within that buffer, as reported by FOX 5 DC. Covered places of public assembly include parks, churches, schools, libraries and hospitals, per the same outlet.

The legal reasoning behind the dismissal drew differing characterizations in local coverage. The Daily Record reported that Chuang found the Justice Department had not alleged the pattern or practice of law-enforcement conduct required under the statute it sued under, writing that the complaint was “devoid of any allegations of actual conduct by law enforcement officers relating in any way” to the ordinance, according to The Daily Record. The outlet also noted that Chuang did not reach the question of whether the firearms ordinance violates the Second Amendment. A separate characterization from the Daily Caller described the ruling as finding that the Justice Department lacked standing to pursue the case altogether — a framing that differs from the Daily Record's account of the court's stated reasoning.

How the Lawsuit Began

The Justice Department sued Montgomery County and two of its public safety agencies on Aug. 3, 2026, challenging the gun law directly. In its lawsuit, the department argued the law was too broad, alleging that a licensed person could not realistically move through the county without entering one of the restricted zones. It further alleged that the restrictions would apply even when someone held a valid carry permit and the property owner allowed the firearm, per the lawsuit's claims as described by FOX 5 DC.

County officials say the ordinance was revised after an April ruling from the Maryland Supreme Court, with the county maintaining that it preserved strong firearm restrictions even as it adjusted the bill's language. The county enacted its updated gun legislation on July 21, 2026, about two weeks before the federal case was filed. The State's Attorney's Office told Bethesda Magazine that no one in the county had been arrested or charged under the law, and said it did not intend to prosecute violations while constitutional challenges were still pending.

County Executive Calls Ruling an Affirmation

County Executive Marc Elrich welcomed the judge's decision, calling it an important affirmation of the county's responsibility to protect public safety. He said the bill was enacted to strengthen and preserve protections around places where neighbors live, learn, worship and gather, and added that the county's actions were grounded in law and intended to protect residents. Elrich also said constitutional rights and lawful measures to prevent gun violence need not be mutually exclusive.

The Justice Department, for its part, said it is assessing the decision and next steps while remaining committed to protecting the Second Amendment rights of law-abiding citizens in Maryland, according to Bethesda Magazine.

A Second, Separate Legal Fight Continues

Monday's dismissal is not the only legal challenge to the county's gun law. A separate federal case brought by the Silver Spring Jewish Center and Rabbi J. Menashe Shapiro remains ongoing after a different judge, Deborah K. Chasanow, granted a preliminary injunction limiting enforcement as it applies to the synagogue and the rabbi specifically. The Daily Record reported that Chasanow wrote in September that the plaintiffs were likely to prevail on arguments that the county's law violates their religious rights under the First Amendment and their right to bear arms under the Second Amendment. That injunction does not bar enforcement of the law against anyone else, per Bethesda Magazine's earlier reporting on the synagogue case.

Maryland's highest court has separately weighed in on the county's underlying authority to regulate firearms near these locations. According to an opinion posted by Maryland Courts, the state's highest court found that Montgomery County did not exceed its authority under the relevant state statute in regulating firearms in or within 100 yards of places of public assembly. That state-level finding is distinct from Chuang's federal ruling and does not resolve the open Second Amendment questions still pending in the synagogue's case.