
For the first time, more Milwaukee students whose schooling is paid for with public money are in schools outside the traditional Milwaukee Public Schools system than inside it.
BizTimes put the split at 52,565 students, or 50.3%, in publicly funded options beyond traditional MPS, and 51,895, or 49.7%, in traditional district schools. Schools report those counts to the state on the third Friday in September. BizTimes said the figures had not yet been audited. The publication reviewed Department of Public Instruction enrollment figures and MPS budget documents on its own. The research underneath was first published by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and conducted by Alan Borsuk, senior fellow in law and public policy at Marquette University.
The two totals in circulation are close and not the same. BizTimes put Milwaukee students in publicly supported schools at about 104,460. In a Nov. 11 report, the Journal Sentinel put this fall's unofficial total at 104,363. The percentage story rides on the unaudited BizTimes breakdown.
A Bigger Roster Than the Milestone
MPS reported 53,922 students in traditional district schools this fall. That roster includes 2,027 children who live outside Milwaukee and attend through open enrollment, according to Borsuk's research as cited by BizTimes. Take the nonresidents out and the city's own traditional-school count is the 51,895.
The district is not empty. It is no longer where most Milwaukee students on public funding go. A district headcount and a citywide share are different measurements, and only one of them just slipped under half.
Choice, Charters, and the Line Next Door
The outside half is not one program. Drawing on DPI documents, BizTimes counted 30,091 students in private schools through the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program and 15,826 in Milwaukee charter schools. Another 4,874 Milwaukee students attend schools in neighboring communities through open enrollment.
The special needs scholarship program enrolled 1,119 students in Milwaukee schools, though city residency was not clear for how many of those students. MPS documents put 655 more students in other non-MPS programs. Private choice schools, charters, open enrollment and those smaller programs are what the 50.3% actually is.
The parental choice program was established in 1990 and was the nation's first publicly funded private-school voucher program. Wisconsin now runs more than one publicly funded private-school choice program. Charter school legislation followed in 1993. The crossover announced this month has been under construction for a generation.
A Long Slide, With One Paper Switch
The Journal Sentinel has tracked the slower version of this story: the share of Milwaukee children enrolled in MPS has fallen almost every year since the 1990s, generally by one or two percentage points. Since the 2020-21 school year, BizTimes' analysis shows traditional MPS enrollment down about 8,700 students. City charter enrollment fell by about 600 over that same stretch. Choice-program enrollment rose by about 1,600.
The sharpest recent drop is partly a change of letterhead. Enrollment in MPS board-authorized charter schools fell nearly 50% from the prior year, largely because Carmen Schools of Science and Technology and Milwaukee College Prep are authorized by UW-Milwaukee this year instead of MPS, BizTimes reported. Those students did not have to leave the city for the district's charter column to shrink.
Milwaukee also has fewer school-age children and smaller households. Birth records cited by the Journal Sentinel show a 15% decline in babies born to Milwaukee mothers from 2020 to 2025. That demographic squeeze and the decades-long shift in school share are both on the record. Neither figure, by itself, explains why any particular family landed where it did.
An earlier look at the charter side, published by Urban Milwaukee in 2024, found that independent charter schools and non-instrumentality MPS charter schools together more than doubled, from 7,323 students in 2006 to 15,695 in 2024. The same account said non-instrumentality charters had been losing students since 2020, and independent charters since 2022. Growth and a later stall can both be true.
Sara Shaw projected that if the relationship between birthrates and first-grade enrollment holds, first-grade enrollment across the city is likely to be 16% to 22% lower in 2029 than it was in 2023. The smaller classes are not a theory waiting on a task force. Some of them have already been born.
The pattern is not only Milwaukee's. Between September 2019 and September 2022, enrollment in Wisconsin public school districts fell by about 36,500 students, about 4%, while voucher programs rose by about 8,800 and independent charters by about 2,000, the Journal Sentinel reported from DPI figures. On Sept. 16, 2022, MPS counted 65,390 students, nearly 3% and about 2,000 fewer than the year before.
Stability First, Then the Funding Argument
Superintendent Brenda Cassellius said she respects every parent's school choice and that MPS has to strengthen its schools so families and students have a real choice. She said the district has made progress on its finances and saw gains in literacy scores on the most recent state Forward Exams. She described the approach as stability first and excellence next. The district still faces financial, academic and facilities challenges. A literacy gain and a facilities problem can occupy the same school year.
Colleston Morgan, president and executive director of City Forward Collective, said public charter and private school sectors are holding steady against declining overall enrollment. He said Milwaukee students outside MPS are the state's largest collection of publicly funded students, and that the milestone should not be treated as a competition between MPS and other Milwaukee schools. The measure he offered is reading, writing, math and whether students are prepared to graduate. He also said Milwaukee is not meeting needed student outcomes and is backsliding in some areas of early literacy, particularly for Black students, and that the city should change its strategy rather than trying to solve education problems through MPS or without MPS as separate projects.
Democrats are set to control the governor's office and both legislative chambers for the first time since 2010, and they have called for increased public-school funding. Governor-elect David Crowley will inherit that argument in a city BizTimes placed with Indianapolis, Washington, D.C., and New Orleans among places reaching a similar enrollment threshold. Morgan said the figures should inform state K-12 funding talks, and that policymakers should account for the majority of Milwaukee students being served outside district schools.
The September counts still have an audit in front of them. The funding debate does not. A little more than half of Milwaukee's publicly supported students are already somewhere other than a traditional MPS classroom, and that is the map the next state budget will have to read.









