Treasure Valley/ Crime & Emergencies

Nampa Man Who Killed Wife’s Lover Seeks Shorter Sentence Than 22 Years to Life

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Nampa Man Who Killed Wife’s Lover Seeks Shorter Sentence Than 22 Years to LifeCourtroom Hearing
Colin Lloyd / Unsplash

A Nampa man sentenced to 22 years to life in prison for gunning down the man he discovered was having an affair with his wife is now asking a judge to shorten that punishment, arguing it is excessive. Saengutone Ty Maria pleaded guilty to first-degree murder for killing Brandon Meseroll, and he is pursuing relief through an Idaho Rule 35 motion that prosecutors are fighting to block.

According to the Idaho Statesman, Maria is asking the court to reduce or correct his sentence, arguing that the punishment he received is too harsh. The Canyon County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has opposed the motion, and a hearing was scheduled for 8:30 a.m. Wednesday, the newspaper reported. Under Idaho Criminal Rule 35, a court may correct a sentence that is illegal on the face of the record at any time, according to the Idaho Supreme Court.

Maria was arrested in August 2025 after 911 calls reported shots fired at a Nampa Holiday Inn Express. The newspaper's earlier report indicates Maria's wife was at the hotel around 9 a.m. on the morning of the shooting and walked toward the car, with Meseroll following, and that Maria demanded her location and threatened to kill their children.

A Night of Tracking, Threats and Weapons

Maria discovered that Meseroll was having an affair with his wife the night before the shooting and used her iCloud account to track her location, per the seed facts tied to the Statesman's reporting. Around 3 a.m., he drove to the Nampa Holiday Inn Express, found his wife's vehicle and drove it home using spare keys. He loaded it with a rifle, shotgun and handgun, returned to the hotel and hid in the trunk.

While waiting, Maria sent messages to his wife about their three children being left home alone and threatened to have a welfare check conducted on them, the facts show. He also left two voicemails for his daughters telling them he loved them and texted his manager asking for the day off to work on his marriage.

Per detective Kyle Ferrari, Maria shot Meseroll approximately 15 times, including twice while he was already on the ground, before fleeing the scene. Maria's wife called 911 after witnessing the shooting. His black Chevy Avalanche appeared in traffic footage near the hotel at 9:12 a.m., about two minutes after the 911 call came in, and police found Maria and brought him in for questioning that evening.

'At Peace' After the Shooting, Then a Clarification

Per detective Ferrari, Maria told investigators he felt at peace after the shooting and that a weight had lifted from his shoulders, though he later clarified he meant he felt relief after confessing. His wife had previously discussed wanting a divorce with him. Per detective Jonathan Styles, Maria also threatened to harm his children while they were sleeping.

Judge Called the Killing Premeditated

Judge Randall S. Grove, who presided over both Maria's guilty plea and sentencing, found that the killing was premeditated and not a crime of passion, the Statesman reported. Grove found that Maria planned and prepared the attack by tracking his wife, obtaining weapons and waiting at the hotel, and said Maria had several hours in which he could have reconsidered his actions. Grove said that if he sentenced Maria solely based on the harm caused, he could not imprison him long enough.

Prosecutors had recommended 18 years to life in prison along with a $5,000 civil penalty for Meseroll's mother, but Grove sentenced Maria to 22 years to life, exceeding that recommendation. Maria was also ordered to pay the $5,000 civil penalty and $245.50 in court costs.

Defense Points to Weight Loss, Suicide Watch, Harassment

In seeking the reduction, Maria's defense described him as previously law-abiding and high-functioning, and said two psychological evaluations found depression connected to his marriage and separation from his children. The defense cited Maria's loss of about 60 pounds over the past year at sentencing. It also said he had been placed on suicide watch.

Maria has argued his punishment is excessive and that he has faced harassment and physical violence in prison. He has reported that inmates pressured him to request better antidepressants so they could buy them, and that inmates made demoralizing and evil comments about his case. Maria has said he is trying to better himself as a Christian and maintain his moral values while incarcerated, and that he is willing to complete recommended classes to demonstrate accountability. He asked the court for leniency and a reasonable sentence reduction, not the minimum 10 years, and said he felt remorse for his actions and knew better.

His defense also noted that the 18-years-to-life sentence prosecutors had originally recommended would have made Maria eligible for parole in his mid-50s. Maria has struggled with depression, childhood abuse and periods of homelessness as a teenager, according to his defense.

Prosecutors Push Back

Deputy prosecutor Angela Stevens argued that Maria had not presented new information relevant to sentencing that the court had not already considered. Stevens also argued that Maria's sentence was consistent with his criminal conduct and was not illegal, unreasonable or unduly harsh, the Statesman reported.

It remains unclear how the court will rule on Maria's Rule 35 motion.