Greater Albuquerque/ Albuquerque/ Politics & Govt

Navajo Panel Rejects San Juan County Data Center After Water Fight

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Navajo Panel Rejects San Juan County Data Center After Water FightSource: Tyler / Unsplash

A Navajo Nation committee has rejected a proposed 599-acre data center and energy park in San Juan County after a nearly four-hour debate that pitted promises of thousands of jobs against fears over water use on a reservation where many homes still lack running water. The Naabik’iyati Committee voted 12 against the lease, four in favor, and seven not voting this month, dealing a setback to a project years in the making near the Nenahnezad Chapter.

The proposal, led by the Navajo Tribal Utility Authority alongside New York-based Lion Point Capital and the Sunshine Fund, called for a campus combining solar power generation, battery storage, natural gas-fired turbines, advanced computing, data center facilities and advanced energy manufacturing, according to Searchlight New Mexico. A site map from the utility authority shows the data center itself would cover 200 of the nearly 600 acres, with the rest devoted to manufacturing and power generation near the Four Corners Generating Station, east of Morgan Lake.

Under the arrangement, the utility authority would hold a 51% stake in the joint venture and control its board. In an email to The New Mexican on behalf of both firms, Jacobsson said no data center tenant had been selected or signed, even as the project moved toward a vote. Jacobsson said discussions with Navajo leaders about the data center component have been happening publicly since at least 2025, even though the Nenahnezad Chapter’s original 2022 resolution endorsed only an initial solar and energy storage project and made no mention of a data center.

Jobs Promise Versus Water Worries

Project consultant Arash Moalemi told the committee during the Nov. 12 hearing that the manufacturing plant and the data center are financially intertwined. “You cannot build the manufacturing itself without the data center, and you cannot build the [high-performance] data center without the manufacturing,” he said, describing the data center as “kind of an anchor financial tenant for that project.” Moalemi said the venture could potentially generate 4,300 to 4,750 full-time jobs at full build-out, primarily in manufacturing energy products such as solar cells and modules, with developers also promising thousands of construction jobs.

Delegate Rickie Nez touted those economic benefits for the region and said the project would generate revenue for the Navajo Nation, while Titus Nez said he supports bringing jobs to the reservation. But Titus Nez also opposed using scarce water for the project, and that tension over water use dominated much of the debate. Moalemi told the committee developers project campus water use of about 2.5 million gallons per day, with Jacobsson saying the manufacturing plant alone would consume roughly 5% to 7% of the utility’s water rights and the data center up to 2% more.

Developers have indicated they intend to build a closed-loop cooling system, but per the same hearing account, the current proposal does not actually require that design or set any cap on water use. The stakes are heightened by the fact that many Navajo Nation households still lack running water, and the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project, designed to deliver fresh water from the San Juan River to eastern Navajo Nation communities, is not expected to begin deliveries until late 2028.

A Rushed Comment Window Draws Fire

A Rushed Comment Window Draws Fire Violet White, of the Leupp Chapter, called the public comment period, which lasted just five days and closed Nov. 11, an insult to Navajo grassroots people in a letter submitted the day after the comment period closed. Tso has said he believes the full council may still reject the project if the same dissenting delegates vote against it again.

The Navajo Nation and the utility authority would not guarantee the project’s debt, though the utility authority must obtain a performance bond from the sublessee under the proposal, with the Navajo Nation listed as a covered party. The proposal could still go before the full Navajo Nation Council for a vote as soon as next month.

Part of a Wider Reservation Fight

The Nenahnezad Chapter dispute lands amid a broader national scramble by developers to site data centers on tribal land as states and cities tighten restrictions elsewhere. Honor the Earth has tracked more than 100 data center proposals in and around tribal lands across the country, as reported by KJZZ. Elsewhere on Navajo land, the LeChee Chapter near Page, Arizona unanimously passed a resolution opposing a separate data center proposal bordering Antelope Canyon, according to The Salt Lake Tribune.

Other tribes have moved more decisively to block similar projects. The Hualapai Tribe enacted a moratorium on data center development across its nearly 1 million-acre reservation in northern Arizona, and the Cherokee Nation’s own task force findings led to a ban on data center projects on its reservation and adjacent trust lands, per KJZZ. The Cheyenne and Arapaho approved a three-year prohibition on tribal lands while studying potential effects, and the Kickapoo Tribe of Oklahoma declared opposition over concerns about strain on utilities and limited job creation, according to Newsweek. Not every tribe is resisting: the Cachil Dehe Band of Wintun Indians announced plans for its own AI and energy infrastructure campus with Colusa Indian Energy and Strata Expanse, Newsweek reported.

The data center is expected to require about 700 megawatts of power, which could supply hundreds of thousands of homes, with the facility drawing on power generated on site and delivering subsidized power to utility customers. New Mexico Governor-elect Deb Haaland has committed to signing an executive order pausing new large-scale data center development in the state on her first day in office, as the state legislature works to develop guardrails for the industry. Project backers have said Haaland’s planned order would not affect tribal land.