Greater Hartford/ Crime & Emergencies

New Haven Agrees to $30M Settlement for Two Wrongfully Convicted Men

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
New Haven Agrees to $30M Settlement for Two Wrongfully Convicted MenSource: Federal Judicial Center, https://www.fjc.gov/history/courthouses.nsf / Wikimedia Commons

New Haven has agreed to pay $30 million to settle two federal civil rights lawsuits brought by George Gould and the estate of Ronald Taylor, two men wrongfully convicted of a 1993 Grand Avenue murder they did not commit. Under the proposed deal, Gould would receive $18 million and Taylor's estate would receive $12 million, according to plaintiffs' attorneys.

The settlement, reached Nov. 13, resolves consolidated federal cases over the killing of New Haven bodega owner Eugenio Vega, according to the New Haven Independent. Vega was found dead in the walk-in refrigerator of his Grand Avenue store on July 4, 1993, his wrists bound and a .38-caliber bullet in his head, per the federal lawsuits described in reporting from the New Haven Register. Gould and Taylor were tried jointly before a jury in 1995 despite no fingerprints or other forensic evidence linking either man to the killing, the lawsuits alleged.

The case against them, the lawsuits claimed, relied almost entirely on testimony that was later admitted to be false. A witness named Noreen Stiles testified she saw Gould and Taylor leave Vega's store after hearing loud voices, screaming, a demand to open a safe and a gunshot — but her account did not hold up over the following decade.

A Witness Who Recanted, Then Recanted Again

Stiles recanted her trial testimony at a 2009 habeas hearing, only to tell detectives in 2012 that her original testimony had been accurate after all, then invoke her Fifth Amendment right and decline to testify at a second habeas trial that same year. A judge denied that habeas petition. By 2013, according to a report from the state's Conviction Integrity Unit, Stiles had recanted her statement to detectives and said her testimony about Gould and Taylor was untrue; in 2017, per that same CIU report, she confirmed she had falsely implicated the two men in the killing.

A judge had briefly released Gould and Taylor on appeal in 2010 on grounds of actual innocence, but the Connecticut Supreme Court reversed that ruling and sent the case back for a new habeas trial. Taylor was permitted to remain at home because of terminal cancer and died in 2011, before that second trial could happen. Accounts of how long each man spent incarcerated vary: the city's version, reported by WFSB, says Gould was incarcerated for nearly 27 years and Taylor for more than 16 years, while the New Haven Independent reports Gould spent 26 years in prison until his sentence was shortened in 2021, and that Taylor died of cancer in 2011 after 16 years behind bars.

Gould was ultimately released from prison in May 2021 after a sentence-modification motion was granted, according to the lawsuit. After review by the state's Conviction Integrity Unit, the state's attorney moved to vacate both convictions in 2024, and a judge approved that motion that February.

Gould Speaks on Decades Lost

Gould said he was relieved his legal ordeal had finally ended, but that no amount of money could compensate for decades of wrongful incarceration, according to the New Haven Register's reporting. He said he hopes his case prompts the New Haven Police Department to examine its practices and prevent another wrongful conviction.

Mayor Justin Elicker apologized to Gould and Taylor and their families, saying it took more than 30 years for them to clear their names, per WFSB. Attorney Nick Brustin said the jury's verdict in a related case preceded the city's decision to settle the Gould and Taylor lawsuits, and that while the settlement offers some closure, it came too late and was too small, with the city's misconduct having devastated two families. New Haven did not immediately respond to a request for comment, the Register reported.

Part of a Costly Pattern for the City

The Gould and Taylor settlement is the fourth and fifth federal civil rights lawsuit the city has settled in the last three months, according to the New Haven Independent. Those five settlements total $77 million and could cost the city at least $116 million to repay over 20 years with interest, per the same WFSB report, and the city plans to seek Board of Alders approval to borrow the full settlement amount.

Other recent payouts include $16.5 million to Adam Carmon and $15.25 million each to Vernon Horn and Marquis Jackson, two men imprisoned for a robbery and murder they did not commit, the Independent reported — though NBC Connecticut described the Horn and Jackson settlement together as totaling $30 million. Separately, a jury awarded Stefon Morant $38 million for a wrongful conviction in a 1990 New Haven double murder, a verdict the city is currently appealing.

NBC Connecticut has reported that Morant and another man, Lewis, are among a group of at least eight New Haven men whose murder convictions were overturned and who are now seeking justice, with some civil cases already won or settled and others still pending. Statewide, a Connecticut Mirror report from February 2025 said eight wrongful-conviction awards totaling $37.6 million were set for legislative review, which would bring the state's total wrongful-conviction payouts to $128.9 million — an average of $5.2 million for each of 25 claimants.