
Nearly a year after fire tore through a stretch of New Plymouth, Idaho, charred debris from the Double Diamond Saloon is still sitting on the property, and neighbors say they are tired of waiting for someone to clean it up. The Nov. 24, 2025, blaze destroyed the saloon and the adjacent Shear Attitude hair salon and damaged other nearby businesses, leaving a scarred lot that residents now watch every time it rains.
According to Idaho News 6, residents Jan Holshevnikoff and Justin Cherry have spent months pushing for action, with Holshevnikoff saying she no longer knows who else to contact after nothing changed and her appeals to state and federal officials failed to bring the cleanup she wanted. Cherry said he has repeatedly asked when someone would take care of the property, and that his own online posts drew offers of dumpsters, equipment, and volunteers ready to help clear the site.
That volunteer effort never got off the ground. Per Cherry, people who showed up to help were told not to enter the property without documentation, and the community cleanup did not proceed after that point. Idaho News 6 reports it has not confirmed why the volunteer effort was halted. Neighbors have also flagged a blocked sidewalk near the site and worry that rain could wash fire debris contaminants into a nearby storm drain and eventually the Payette River.
Environmental Regulators Say They Found No Violations
The Idaho Department of Environmental Quality told Idaho News 6 it had received complaints about the site and investigated as appropriate, but the agency said it identified no environmental hazards or violations and has not tested the debris or runoff itself. DEQ also said it has no evidence of a stormwater discharge from the property violating the Clean Water Act, though it did not specify where the drain in question ultimately discharges. Separately, EPA Region 10 is aware of residents' asbestos concerns tied to the burned structures.
Resident Ginny Barton told the station that getting straight answers from officials has been difficult, though she said residents appreciate having the chance to be heard. Her bottom line, as relayed to Idaho News 6: people in New Plymouth simply want the property cleaned up.
City Hall Has Moved Slowly Since a December Vote
The New Plymouth City Council voted in December 2025 to declare the Double Diamond a dangerous building requiring demolition and removal, and city code sets deadlines for clearing demolition debris and gives the city a process to address nuisances and seek repayment from the property owner. Idaho News 6 notes that demolition and removal are required once the necessary investigations allow them to proceed, but the station says city officials have not provided a substantive explanation for the delay, a timeline, or details on planned enforcement.
Months later, the council took up the matter again. The New Plymouth City Council unanimously approved a 90-day demolition permit extension, according to argusobserver.com, with that extension approved 4-0 on July 21. The same report put the estimated demolition cost at $135,000, with bids already submitted by two contractors.
Council Tables Nuisance Vote as Insurance Dispute Lingers
Progress stalled again in October. The council voted to table a series of proposed actions tied to removing the Double Diamond's remains during its Oct. 20 meeting, the outlet reported, including measures that would have declared the remains a continuing nuisance and public safety hazard, authorized abatement, and issued a notice of violation. Mayor Tyson Flannery said City Attorney Jill Holinka requested the delay, and the same report said owner Robin Cusma continues to struggle with insurance to pay for cleanup and demolition.
County assessor's records identify Lost Creek Investments as the property owner, with Cusma listed in recorded documents as a manager or member of that company. A lender filed a lawsuit in 2025 seeking foreclosure of a mortgage on the property, though a foreclosure notice does not establish that the foreclosure was completed, and Idaho News 6 says it has not confirmed whether that litigation is affecting the cleanup timeline. Cusma had not responded to multiple requests for comment as of the station's publication.
Idaho News 6 also sought records on permits, extensions, and enforcement actions tied to the site, and reached out to Fruitland Fire and Paul Davis regarding the investigation and any work done there. A sign at the property identifies NEFCO Fire Investigations as involved in the case, but a NEFCO representative told the station the company could have been hired by either the owner or an insurance company and declined to disclose case details, calling it a private investigation; NEFCO did not identify its client.
Fire Marshal's Office Keeps Investigation Open
The Idaho State Fire Marshal's Office told the station its investigation into the fire's origin and cause remains active and that no final report was available while the case stays open, though it said it would share releasable information once the investigation concludes. The office's statement did not address whether demolition or debris removal could proceed while that investigation is still underway.
Idaho law gives cities broad authority here: a statute from the Idaho State Legislature allows municipalities to declare what counts as a nuisance and to remove or abate it at the expense of the party responsible for creating or maintaining it. How New Plymouth applies that authority to the Double Diamond site going forward remains to be seen. A city official told KTVB the city had no comment on the matter, according to Yahoo News. For now, Idaho News 6 says it will keep seeking records and responses about what cleanup requirements remain and what progress, if any, residents can expect next.









