
New York lawmakers have passed a bill that would move e-cigarette tax collection from the retail counter to the wholesale level, and it's now sitting with Gov. Kathy Hochul as advocacy groups push hard in opposite directions over whether she should sign it. The state legislature passed the measure in both houses, and Hochul has said she is considering it, as reported by Spectrum News 1.
At issue is a structural change that sounds simple but could have an outsized effect on how much tax actually gets paid. Under current law, New York imposes a 20% tax on the retail sale of vapor products; the bill would set a wholesale tax rate of 20% instead, according to Spectrum News 1. Kevin O'Flaherty, associate vice president for state and local policy at the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, said that swapping a 20% retail tax for a 20% wholesale tax effectively cuts the tax by more than half, since wholesale prices are generally less than half of retail prices, per the same report.
Tobacco-Control Group Pushes For a Veto
O'Flaherty recommended a wholesale tax rate of about 48% if the goal is to maintain the current effective tax level, Spectrum News 1 reported. The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids has said the legislation would make e-cigarettes cheaper for children and has posted an online action alert urging people to tell Hochul to veto it. The group wants her to reject the bill and instead propose the same wholesale-shift changes through her upcoming budget process, according to the outlet.
The group's objection isn't to the wholesale-tax concept itself — it supports shifting collection to the wholesale level in principle — but to the specific rate chosen and the bill's immediate effective date, which O'Flaherty said makes future amendments more complicated, per Spectrum News 1. The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance has said the bill does not provide tools to effectively enforce the tax, the station reported. A national tobacco organization has also called on Hochul to veto the bill, according to the same report.
Convenience Stores Say the Bill Targets Illegal Sellers
Alison Ritchie, president of the Association of Convenience Stores, has pushed back directly on the tobacco-control group's framing. She said the bill does not lower taxes or make nicotine products cheaper, and that it instead moves tax collection to the appropriate point in the distribution chain so the state can identify and hold violators accountable, per Spectrum News 1's reporting. Ritchie said the measure would give New York new tools to crack down on distributors of illegal, unregulated vaping products, strengthening enforcement against illegal flavored vapes and helping remove them from streets and from underage users. The Association of Convenience Stores has urged Hochul to sign the bill, and the group has questioned the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids' position on the legislation, according to the outlet.
Separately, City & State New York has described the legislation as shifting the state's existing 20% tax from retail sales to the wholesale price a dealer pays a distributor, and reported that the bill would require every vapor-product distributor to obtain a license from the state Department of Tax and Finance, plus create a public directory to track how product moves through the supply chain. If Hochul signs the measure, state tax officials would gain new authority to inspect distributor supply chains and revoke licenses, that outlet reported. Earlier coverage from POLITICO in June described the bill differently, characterizing it as imposing a 32-cent-per-milliliter tax on closed and prefilled vapes alongside an 8% tax on other vape products; that same report noted a spokesperson for Hochul said she would review the legislation.
A Four-Year Push and Disputed Revenue Numbers
State Sen. Leroy Comrie, a Democrat, said the bill is intended to make it more difficult for distributors to funnel e-cigarettes to minors and to strengthen enforcement of the state's 2020 ban on flavored vape products, according to Spectrum News 1. New York currently sets the minimum purchase age for vape products at 21. Comrie said the legislation has been under development for four years, and that any issues with the tax structure can still be corrected working with the governor's office, the station reported.
Revenue projections remain a flashpoint. City & State reported that health organizations opposing the bill estimated it would reduce state tax revenue by roughly $20 million annually, while POLITICO reported that the bill's sponsors said their own analysis found revenue would stay neutral or even increase. New York is among 34 states plus the District of Columbia that levied an excise tax on vaping products as of January 2026, according to the Tax Foundation, which found wholesale vaping tax rates ranging as high as 95% in Minnesota and Washington and 92% in Vermont, with retail tax states ranging from 12.5% in California — on top of a separate 54.27% wholesale tax there — up to 60% in Maryland.
New York City's health department has also pointed to enforcement efforts against illegal vape distribution, noting that the city filed a federal lawsuit against four major distributors of illegal flavored vapes in 2023, including the nation's largest vape distributor, followed by a second lawsuit against 11 wholesalers in 2024, according to a 2025 city health department posting. Whether Hochul ultimately signs or vetoes the bill now before her remains an open question as both sides continue to make their case.









