New York City/ Real Estate & Development

Newark Is One of Only 3 U.S. Metros Where Home Sellers Still Hold the Edge

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Newark Is One of Only 3 U.S. Metros Where Home Sellers Still Hold the EdgeSource: Djflem / Wikimedia Commons

Newark homeowners are still holding the cards in one of the tightest housing markets in the country. New data shows the city is one of just three major U.S. metro areas where sellers continue to have the upper hand over buyers, even as that advantage has started to shrink.

Newark had 14.3% fewer sellers than buyers in October, according to Redfin, which classifies any market with more than 10% fewer sellers than buyers as a seller’s market. Redfin says the only other seller’s markets among the nation’s 50 most populous metros were Nassau County, New York, and Montgomery County, Pennsylvania — all three in the Northeast. The three markets tied for the fewest seller’s markets among major metros in Redfin’s records dating back to 2016, matching a previous low set in April 2020.

Redfin estimates its seller counts from active MLS listings and its buyer counts from its own proprietary data combined with MLS figures, describing the dataset as a seasonally adjusted monthly estimate of people actively in the market. The company cautions that the estimates are subject to revision.

Newark's Gap Is Narrowing

Redfin's October report says Newark's seller-buyer gap shrunk from 17.6% in September to 14.3% in October.

Nassau County remained the tightest market in the country in October, with 24.7% fewer sellers than buyers, according to Keysnews. Montgomery County followed with a 12.1% gap. A month earlier, in September, Redfin had listed Montgomery County at 20.1% and Nassau County at 28.3%, alongside Milwaukee and San Francisco as additional seller's markets that have since fallen out of the top tier.

What the Imbalance Means for Buyers

Redfin senior economist Asad Khan said buyers in these Northeast seller's markets may find themselves with less leverage than shoppers elsewhere in the country. “They may have less room to negotiate, especially on desirable, move-in-ready homes, and could face multiple-offer situations,” Khan told Keysnews.

Prices in the three seller's markets are moving accordingly. Home-sale prices rose an average of 3.3% year over year across the three seller's markets in October, compared with just a 0.3% uptick across buyer's markets nationally, per the same Redfin report. Locally, the median sale price in the Newark area was $613,591 in September, up 4% from a year earlier, according to SNJ Today.

Not every deal in the region is closing smoothly, though. SNJ Today reports that 11.7% of home-purchase contracts in the Newark area were canceled in September, and 11.9% fell through in the nearby New Brunswick area — both figures below the 14.5% national cancellation rate the outlet cited.

A National Picture Tilted Sharply Toward Sellers

Newark's situation is an outlier. Nationwide, there were an estimated 70.5% more sellers than buyers in October, the largest gap in Redfin's records dating back to 2013. Redfin estimated just 895,752 homebuyers active in the U.S. market that month, also the lowest level in its records. The imbalance was especially stark in Miami, where sellers outnumbered buyers by nearly 196%, while the broader New York metro area was itself a buyer's market, with 17.7% more sellers than buyers.

The New York Post also reported on Newark's standing among the nation's few seller's markets; the Post can be found at nypost.com.