Hudson Valley/ Real Estate & Development

Newburgh's First Hotel in Nearly 150 Years Takes Shape on Grand Street

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Newburgh's First Hotel in Nearly 150 Years Takes Shape on Grand StreetMasonic Temple — Approximate Hotel Project Site
Google Street View

Three long-vacant buildings on Grand Street are planned for a new mix of hotel rooms, restaurants, retail, and conference space, in a project that developers say will bring activity to a stretch of downtown that has sat empty for years. The 74-room hotel is being developed by Sims and Kirsten Foster, the husband-and-wife team behind Foster Supply Hospitality, who plan to open it by the end of 2027, according to Mid Hudson News. The couple already operates five hotels and four restaurants in Sullivan County; the project marks their move into the City of Newburgh.

Foster Supply Hospitality bought the three adjacent vacant historic buildings from the county in 2021, according to The New York Times. Reported estimates of the project’s cost range from $45 million to $46 million: Mid Hudson News put it at $46 million, the Times cited $45.9 million, and the Times Herald-Record described it as a $45 million development. By December 2025, Mid Hudson News reported that Sims Foster had secured financing and closed on the three buildings.

The hotel is located about one block from Newburgh's Hudson River waterfront, near the heart of downtown. The Times Herald-Record has separately described the site as steps from SUNY Orange and Broadway.

How the Project Fits Downtown Plans

Newburgh’s 2021 Downtown Revitalization Initiative application said most of its target area overlapped the East End Historic District and noted that investors could use historic-preservation tax credits and other incentives. The application also envisioned transforming Broadway into a pedestrian-friendly boulevard with dedicated transit and bicycle lanes, presenting that as a plan rather than a completed improvement, according to the City of Newburgh’s Downtown Revitalization Initiative. The City of Newburgh’s Local Waterfront Revitalization Program describes the north side of Broadway between Liberty and Grand streets as an area of commercial and institutional uses.

What's Inside the Three Buildings

The project repurposes three distinct structures, each taking on its own role. The former YMCA building will include hotel rooms and a spa. The Masonic Temple building will hold corporate conference facilities and large event spaces, along with a first-floor restaurant and bar and a fourth-floor cocktail lounge.

The former American Legion post is part of the project. Across the three buildings, the finished hotel will offer 74 rooms at a variety of price points, along with a rooftop bar overlooking the Hudson River. The New York Times has reported that the project broke ground in December and secured a 12-year Payment in Lieu of Taxes agreement with the City of Newburgh.

A Cost That Kept Climbing

The project's 2021 PILOT application estimated its cost at $24.4 million. The New York Times has reported that the project is expected to open in late 2027.

The New York Times has described the project as Newburgh's first hotel in nearly 150 years.

Local Business Owners Watch and Wait

Brandon Grimilia co-owns Downstate Newburgh, a Liberty Street restaurant serving Mexico City-inspired cuisine. He and his partner chose Newburgh because they felt the city needed the cafe.

The Fosters describe themselves simply as owners, operators, renovators, and concept designers.