
A skincare entrepreneur in Manhattan's NoMad neighborhood says she has spent more than a year fending off confused men wandering into her salon by mistake, sometimes while her clients were in bathrobes, all because of what she describes as an alleged brothel operating one floor above her business. Ekaterina Durova, the 38-year-old owner of Katya Young Studios, says the chaos has turned her third-floor storefront at 226 Fifth Avenue into the unwilling downstairs neighbor of an operation she says has brought her nothing but trouble.
According to the New York Post, Durova's business offers facials, lymphatic massages and other skincare treatments ranging from $150 to $350, and has served roughly 300 clients a month for the past four years. Her third-floor elevator, she says, opens directly into her studio, which has made it easy for men looking for the operation upstairs, known as Executive Spas, to end up at her door instead. Durova told the outlet that clients have sometimes been in robes when men barged in, mistaking her salon for the business above.
New York regulates esthetics and massage therapy as separate professions. The state defines esthetics as appearance-enhancing services involving areas such as the face, neck, arms and legs, and requires a separate license for the business itself; massage therapy has its own licensing requirements and scope of practice. That distinction matters in a building where businesses may both describe their services as spa treatments, but it does not establish whether any particular operator is properly licensed. New York’s esthetics licensing rules and massage-therapy requirements set out the separate standards.
Allegations of Threats and Bodily Fluids in Shared Spaces
Durova, a licensed esthetician who works alongside a team of 10 employees, says the disruption goes well beyond wandering customers. She described x-rated activity, dirty shared areas, bodily fluids left in the elevator and threats from what she called the upstairs bosses, according to the same report. She also said an upstairs boss once threatened to destroy her and called her a bitch in Russian — a detail that lands differently given Durova, who was born in Russia and is married to a U.S. citizen, says she now lives in fear.
“It's a nightmare for me that never ends,” Durova said, according to the Post's report. “I'm afraid all the time.”
Durova said the women connected to the upstairs operation come and go, arriving with suitcases, staying briefly, then getting replaced by others. In one instance, she said, she approached a woman about noise only to find her half naked, seemingly disoriented and speaking Spanish. Durova said the business operates 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and that she has complained to the landlord since June 2025 without relief.
The dispute also fits a broader, though not location-specific, pattern researchers have documented in New York. A 2019 study mapped 413 sexually oriented massage parlors in the city and 397 in Los Angeles County, finding that the New York locations clustered mostly in Manhattan; the authors said proximity to customer workplaces appeared to help explain the pattern. The study used listings from a ratings website and cautioned that its observational findings could not establish cause and effect or describe conditions at any particular business. The study’s published abstract summarizes its findings.
Calls to 911 and a Reported NYPD Raid
Per the Post's reporting, Durova says she has called 911 more than 200 times, with police sometimes responding and other times ignoring her calls. She also reported suspected prostitution activity creating an unsafe environment to 311, the Department of Buildings and consumer affairs officials, and 311 forwarded her calls to the NYPD for further action, the outlet reported. The NYPD reportedly raided the alleged brothel on October 15, 2025, and removed several women, according to Durova and a signed court affidavit cited in the report — but the operation resumed business the very next day, Durova said.
The Post also reported that the NYPD had not responded to its inquiries about the raid at the time of publication.
Landlord's Lawsuit Cites Investigator's Affidavit
Court papers cited by the outlet show that 226 Fifth Ave LLC filed a lawsuit to evict the tenant, listed in the filings as Health Spa NYC LLC, which operated under the name Executive Spas after moving into the building in May 2025. The landlord reportedly sent the fourth-floor spa notice that its lease would terminate on May 5 over unresolved lease violations, and alleged in court papers that online advertising linked to the tenant supported a good-faith belief the premises remained used for illicit purposes. The Post reported that the business advertises on Bedpage.com in the escorts section. Executives Spa NYC's own website lists its address as 226 Fifth Avenue, fourth floor, and says it opened its doors in June, without specifying the year.
New York City law provides a separate civil route for addressing alleged prostitution-related nuisances: the city’s corporation counsel may sue in state Supreme Court to enjoin a public nuisance. The code says two or more prostitution convictions at a location within the preceding year create presumptive evidence of a nuisance, while also allowing other evidence, including a site’s general reputation. That city enforcement power is distinct from the landlord’s reported lease-termination and eviction case, which turns on the lease and the claims made in that proceeding. The city’s nuisance-abatement law defines the standard.
Central to the landlord's case is a sworn affidavit from Christopher Eng, a private investigator the landlord hired, according to the report. Eng said a woman collected a $200 cash house fee before leading him to a private room, where she asked him to strip naked and lie facedown, gave him a light massage, and touched his intimate parts, the affidavit states. The Post reported that a woman at the business offered sexual intercourse for $400, two sexual encounters for $800, and oral sex and dancing for $300, before Eng ended the transaction and left. Health Spa NYC LLC has argued it is a legitimate business and is contesting the eviction, according to the outlet.









