North Jersey/ Politics & Govt

Nutley Residents Grill Officials Over Possible 65-Megawatt Data Center at ON3

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 10, 2026
Nutley Residents Grill Officials Over Possible 65-Megawatt Data Center at ON3275 Kingsland St. — Approximate Site of Proposed Data Center
Google Street View

A sign advertising 65 megawatts of power and zoning approval at Nutley's former Hoffman LaRoche campus has set off a wave of resident questions about noise, water use and electric bills, spilling into the township's Nov. 5 Board of Commissioners meeting — the first held in the newly renovated commissioners chambers. Residents pressed officials on whether a data center is actually coming to the 11-acre ON3 redevelopment site at 275 Kingsland Street, and what protections would exist if one is built.

The sign, placed by developer Prism Capital Partners, led residents to start asking the township directly whether a data center was in the works, according to the Township of Nutley. Township officials have said the advertisement reflected zoning permissions rather than approval of a specific project, and that the Planning Board has not received a formal application to build a data center at the address. As TAPinto Nutley reported, Mayor John Kelly told residents at the meeting that no data center application was before the Planning Board, though he said residents would be able to raise concerns and question professionals at public hearings if one is ever submitted.

The ON3 site's path to allowing a data center traces back to litigation over a proposed truck terminal and warehouse there. Settlement terms were reached around 2023 and 2024, with the agreement finalized in 2025, and the developer withdrew its truck terminal plan in exchange for a data center becoming one of several permitted uses at the property. Nutley's ordinance establishing that overlay zone states it would let the property “be transformed into a data center or other uses as specified in the redevelopment plan,” per the Township of Nutley. Resident Laura Valente cited that settlement agreement at the meeting, per TAPinto Nutley, and the township has separately noted that the former Hoffman LaRoche campus generated roughly 10% of Nutley's tax revenue.

What a Future Application Would Actually Face

If a formal data center application is ever filed, township officials say it would go before the Planning Board, which would review noise, stormwater, energy demand, traffic and other regulations under New Jersey's Municipal Land Use Law — with residents able to weigh in at hearings, per TAPinto Nutley. Commissioner Joseph Scarpelli questioned who would be responsible for increased water and wastewater demands if a data center is built, while Commissioner Alphonse Petracco raised concerns about whether current environmental safeguards would adequately protect residents down the line, according to the outlet's account of the meeting.

Residents in attendance raised a broader list of worries, including electricity costs, water consumption, noise, and environmental and public health impacts, as well as possible noise-related sleep disturbances and headaches, per TAPinto Nutley. Commissioner Rob Garber pointed to an existing facility in Vineland while raising noise enforcement questions, a reference to a separate, ongoing dispute there. New Jersey regulators have fined the DataOne data center there $1.07 million for installing and operating 62 large natural-gas generators without required permits, according to the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, and the agency gave the facility 45 days to obtain permits or stop operating.

Pollution Fight in Vineland Looms Over the Debate

The Vineland case has become a flashpoint statewide even though it involves a different facility with its own separate permitting history. More than 100 noise complaints about DataOne have been filed with the Cumberland County Department of Health since March, many pointing to the generators as a suspected source, according to The Guardian. A Rutgers professor cited by the same report estimated the generators emitted about 140 tons of nitrogen oxides in 2025, with experts estimating the full 62-generator fleet could top 1,500 tons annually at full use. DataOne has requested a hearing to contest the state's fine and argue its generators do not require permits in the first place, NJ.com reported.

Nutley already has a second data center in its midst for comparison: a roughly 130,000-square-foot facility at 492 River Road, which GI Partners acquired in 2018. That outlet also reported that Prism's approval allows the company to use the 11-acre Kingsland Street parcel for a major data center and other permitted uses, according to Data Center Dynamics.

State Lawmakers Weigh In at the Meeting

Assemblywoman Carmen Morales and Assemblyman Michael Venezia, who both attended the Nov. 5 meeting, outlined two recently signed state laws meant to address data center concerns, per TAPinto Nutley's reporting. Senate Bill S3379, signed in August 2026, requires data centers to report water and energy consumption every six months to the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities — a requirement the Office of the Governor says is part of a broader four-pillar plan addressing clean energy, infrastructure costs, community benefits and prevailing wages. A separate state notice says the law also directs the Board of Public Utilities to set electric-service standards for large data-center customers and cost-allocation rules meant to keep other ratepayers from subsidizing them, according to the New Jersey Department of Community Affairs.

New Jersey law has also established a separate electricity rate classification intended to shield residential customers from certain large-facility costs, requiring data centers to pay for at least 85% of their reserved electrical capacity even when actual usage is lower. Commissioner Thomas Evans asked whether that rate structure would actually protect residents from costs tied to rising data center demand, including facilities in neighboring states. Venezia explained that New Jersey shares a regional electricity grid with 12 other states, meaning increased demand elsewhere can still affect New Jersey ratepayers — a dynamic a Rutgers State Policy Lab study attributes to the fact that New Jersey buys power through the PJM Interconnection, a wholesale market spanning 13 states and Washington, D.C. That same study found that, through 2024, having a data center nearby raised a typical New Jersey bill by only about $2.09 a month, an effect that disappeared entirely once researchers controlled for other factors at the utility-territory level.

A Proposed Moratorium Gets Mixed Reception

Garber pressed on whether state reporting requirements would prompt immediate action or mostly inform future regulation, and separately asked whether state resources would help Nutley evaluate a data center application if one is ever filed, according to TAPinto Nutley. He also asked Venezia and Morales to consider co-sponsoring Assembly Bill A5663, introduced Oct. 19, which would temporarily prohibit construction of certain new data centers while the state Department of Environmental Protection studies their impacts. Under the bill as described at the meeting, the DEP would have up to 15 months to report findings to the governor and Legislature, with the moratorium remaining in effect for an additional 90 days after that report is submitted; the bill would exempt data centers already approved or under construction before it takes effect.

Venezia agreed to review A5663 and said he was open to a short-term moratorium, while cautioning against measures that could unnecessarily restrict economic development. “Everything here is a work in progress,” he said, per TAPinto Nutley. Morales said the bill has been referred to the Assembly Science, Innovation and Technology Committee, on which she serves, but is not yet scheduled for consideration; she noted roughly 25 data center-related bills are currently pending in the Legislature. Neither lawmaker committed to co-sponsoring the bill at the meeting. “Do I agree? I think we need a study. We need to understand what is happening,” Morales said, adding later: “Can we guarantee that the guardrails that we're setting today aren't going to impact tomorrow? No, we can't guarantee that because we just don't know.”

Venezia noted that continuous noise measurements, something residents have asked about given concerns over sleep disruption and headaches, could add municipal costs and administrative burdens tied to equipment and personnel; current state data center reporting requirements do not include noise monitoring. For now, the ON3 data center question remains unresolved in Nutley, subject to whatever formal application — if any — eventually comes before the township for review.