New York City/ Food & Drinks

NYC Thanksgiving Dinner Hits $184, Up 15% as Turkey and Milk Prices Spike

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
NYC Thanksgiving Dinner Hits $184, Up 15% as Turkey and Milk Prices SpikeSource: Andre Carrotflower / Wikimedia Commons

A full Thanksgiving spread in New York City will run shoppers $184.43 this year, a 15% jump from 2025, according to a survey that priced 18 holiday grocery staples at six supermarket chains across the five boroughs. Apple cider had the biggest increase, followed by milk and pumpkin, while a handful of items actually got cheaper or held steady.

The tally comes from the New York Post, whose reporter Shane Galvin compared prices for the same basket of Thanksgiving items at six chains spread across the city's five boroughs. At Morton Williams on Bleecker Street in Greenwich Village, a 20-pound Bell & Evans young turkey rang up at $79.80, a 17% increase over last year, per the same survey.

Shopper Carole Miller, 89, didn't mince words about what she found on the shelves there. “The meat is outrageous,” she said, according to the Post's report. Still, she wasn't backing off her holiday plans: “I'm gonna buy it regardless of what the price is,” she told the paper.

Milk, Pumpkin and Cider Prices All Climbed

Turkey wasn't the only line item stinging shoppers. Farmland whole milk was priced at $8.99 per half-gallon, up 50% from $5.99 a year earlier, the survey found. Libby's 100% Pure Pumpkin rose to $4.29, a 43% increase, while a Whole Foods nine-inch pumpkin pie climbed to $13.99, up 19% from as low as $11.75 in 2025, per the same report.

Apple cider also jumped sharply, to $6.99 from $3.99 in 2025, a 75% increase, the survey found. That spike follows a rough growing season for the state's orchards: New York apple growers suffered an estimated $30 million in losses so far in 2026 after a spring freeze damaged the harvest, according to the New York governor's office. The state said producers in the affected regions reported losses topping that figure, and the resulting disaster designation allows farmers to apply for USDA low-interest emergency loans.

Not every item in the Post's basket got more expensive. Idahoan boxed mashed potatoes fell by 50 cents, a 10% decrease, and at least eight of the surveyed Thanksgiving products held steady year over year, the report found.

Fixed Incomes Feel the Squeeze

For some shoppers, the math is less about percentages and more about timing. Angelo Hernandez, 66, told the Post that “the milk, the bread, the fruits, meats all went up.” He and his wife lean on their son to bring the turkey for their Thanksgiving table, the paper reported, and Hernandez noted that retirees receive income once a month, unlike workers who get paid every week — a gap that makes price spikes sting harder for those on fixed budgets.

New York's cost pressures show up in national surveys too, though not everyone measures the same basket. The American Farm Bureau Federation's 2025 Thanksgiving survey put New York's per-person dinner cost 20% above the national average and nearly 9% above the Northeast average, according to the New York Farm Bureau. That survey calculated New York's classic meal for 10 at $66.06, nearly 20% above the national figure of $55.18. The state organization pointed to labor shortages, rapidly increasing farm wages and rising production costs, as well as a higher-than-average cost of living, as drivers of New York's elevated grocery prices.

A Different Survey Tells a Different Story

Nationally, turkey prices moved in the opposite direction of what New Yorkers experienced at the register. The Farm Bureau's national survey, covered by Fb.org, priced a 16-pound frozen turkey at $21.50, or $1.34 per pound, down 16.3% from the prior year. That survey found its overall classic Thanksgiving meal cost fell 5% from 2024, marking a third straight year of declines, with half of its tracked ingredients actually getting cheaper.

Retail meal deals this season reflect that broader softening even as the Post's NYC basket climbed. Walmart said its 2026 Holiday Meal Basket, serving 10 people for $35, cost 12% less than the same assortment the year before, according to NBC New York. Aldi advertised feeding 10 people for less than $39, Target brought back its $30 meal for six for a second straight year, and Lidl offered a basket serving up to 10 for $34.40 through Nov. 25 — though Grocery Dive reported Lidl's loyalty-member price at $35.86 and Aldi's bundle at $38.74, figures that differ from NBC New York's numbers.

Wegmans, meanwhile, matched last year's price on a Thanksgiving bundle serving eight for under $5 per person, Grocery Dive reported. Despite the deals on offer, consumer sentiment remains jittery: an Omnisend survey found that between 33% and 43% of consumers polled expected to spend more on holiday food than last year, and about half said hosting feels significantly more stressful than it did a year ago, according to the same outlet.