Tampa/ Food & Drinks

O'Keefe's Tavern Reopens on Gulf-to-Bay, and Clearwater Crowds Follow

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
O'Keefe's Tavern Reopens on Gulf-to-Bay, and Clearwater Crowds FollowSource: Google Street View

O'Keefe's Tavern has reopened in the former home of Capogna's Dugout at 1653 Gulf-to-Bay Blvd. in Clearwater, and the crowds have already found it. The Irish pub quietly relocated in late October after decades as a staple on South Fort Harrison Avenue near downtown, trading one well-worn Clearwater address for another with its own long history.

O'Keefe's had operated at 1219 S. Fort Harrison Ave. since 1961, according to the Tampa Bay Times, which first reported in August that the tavern was leaving its longtime home and moving into the building formerly occupied by Capogna's Dugout. A Tampa Bay Beacons report says the tavern reopened at 1653 Gulf-to-Bay Blvd., with crowds following it to the new address.

A Sale to BayCare Set the Move in Motion

The relocation traces back to a real estate deal: BayCare bought O'Keefe's former Clearwater site for $4 million, according to the Tampa Bay Business Journal. The outlet noted the healthcare system's acquisition sits adjacent to its downtown Clearwater hospital, putting the former pub site within reach of BayCare's existing campus footprint.

The sale wasn't the first signal of change for the property. A year earlier, in August 2025, the Business Journal had reported that O'Keefe's Irish Pub in Clearwater could become the site of 82 apartments. That proposal predated the BayCare purchase, and the business journal's coverage did not establish what became of it once the hospital system stepped in as buyer.

Opening Date Slipped From Tentative September Plan

When news of the move first broke, the timeline looked tighter. St. Pete Catalyst reported in mid-August that a tentative opening was scheduled for mid-September. That target came and went; the tavern didn't actually reopen until late October, per the Times' latest reporting, a gap of roughly six weeks from the original plan.

The new location carries its own weight in Clearwater's dining history. Capogna's Dugout had been a Clearwater institution for more than 50 years before it closed, according to the Tampa Bay Times. The restaurant had already shut down after hurricanes Helene and Milton battered the region in 2024, reopened in spring 2025, and closed again on June 26.

Two Clearwater Landmarks, One Address

The result is a stretch of Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard now carrying the legacy of two long-running local businesses under one roof. O'Keefe's spent decades as a fixture near downtown Clearwater before the BayCare sale pushed it out, and it has landed in a building that itself spent more than half a century serving the same community before storm damage and an uncertain second act caught up with it.

For now, the headline fact is simple: the doors are open, and people are showing up. A Tampa Bay Beacons report says the new spot opens at 11, with crowds following O'Keefe's Tavern to Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard once word got out that it had reopened.