
The Ohio Senate voted 31-1 this week to require cities and villages to get voter approval before installing traffic-enforcement cameras, sending the measure to the House as communities across the state continue collecting millions of dollars from the devices. Senate Bill 340 now moves to the Ohio House, where a companion bill is already pending.
The bill is sponsored by state Sen. Tom Patton, a Republican from Strongsville who has pushed numerous bills over the years to limit red-light camera use, some of which were tossed by courts, according to Cleveland.com. Under current Ohio law, traffic cameras are legal in municipalities but banned in counties and townships, a prohibition the Ohio Legislature enacted and that the Ohio Supreme Court has not yet reviewed, per the same report. Patton has argued the fines hit families hard, saying they can cost a couple hundred dollars at a time when camera companies — often headquartered outside Ohio and sometimes outside the country — collect a percentage of each violation.
A Near-Unanimous Vote With Bipartisan Support
Most of the Senate's minority-party members joined Republicans in backing the bill, including Democratic Sen. Kent Smith of Euclid. Smith said he appreciated the majority party bringing forward legislation that requires voters to be heard, adding that he thought letting voters decide was a good idea, according to the Cleveland.com report.
Patton has cited national data to argue voters tend to reject the cameras when given the chance, saying voters rejected traffic cameras in more than 91% of elections. That tracks with figures reported earlier this year by cleveland.com, which found that of 46 elections nationwide seeking voter approval of traffic cameras since 1991, only four passed — including just one of 14 such votes in Ohio. That same report described House Bill 843 and Senate Bill 340 as identical pieces of legislation moving through separate chambers.
Cities Say Cameras Fund Safety — and Their Budgets
Local governments have defended traffic cameras as a way to promote public safety, particularly in school zones, even as the revenue they generate has become central to some municipal budgets. In Newburgh Heights, a village the Canton Repository reported took in more than $4 million in traffic-camera revenue between July 2024 and June 2025, officials say the money is central to local operations. Mayor Trevor Elkins has said about 70% of those cited pay up.
Cities and villages that keep their cameras running lose state local government fund dollars equal to the fines they collect, a penalty the Ohio Supreme Court upheld as constitutional in 2022, according to Court News Ohio. Elkins has said Newburgh Heights loses about $98,000 a year in state funding as a result of keeping its cameras.
Nearby Communities Have Already Voted Cameras Down
Ohio voters have weighed in on traffic cameras before, and the results have often gone against the devices. Cleveland voters amended the city charter in 2014 to ban the city's use of traffic cameras, the Canton Repository noted.
Safety Advocates Push Back
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety opposed Senate Bill 340, with the group's president, Catherine Chase, arguing that automated enforcement supplements traditional policing without requiring an officer to make a traffic stop. Chase has said law enforcement officers risk their lives on roadways every day and cannot be everywhere to catch every violation. A vendor representative separately cited a Federal Highway Administration figure linking fixed speed cameras to reductions of up to 54% in crashes and 47% in injury crashes on some urban roadways, according to cleveland.com's earlier report.
A proposed Ohio camera program would have a police officer review images. Municipalities that already use cameras would also need voter approval before modifying, extending or renewing their camera contracts if the bills become law, according to Government Technology. With the Senate's 31-1 vote behind it, Senate Bill 340 now awaits action in the Ohio House, where its identical companion bill is also pending.









