Western New York/ Food & Drinks

One Pie Pizza in West Seneca

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 11, 2026
One Pie Pizza in West Seneca2185 Clinton St. — Unverified Street View Scene
Google Street View

One Pie Pizza is a Buffalo pizzeria serving pies at its West Seneca location.

Step Out Buffalo dates the business's opening to 2015.

The shop is listed at 2185 Clinton Street in West Seneca.

Clinton Street's Commercial Character

For broader context, the Town of West Seneca's comprehensive plan described Clinton Street east of the town center as an area of scattered commercial activity and neighborhood services.

What's On the Menu

The menu gives traditional Buffalo-style pizza its own twist and includes gluten-free options, according to One Pie Pizza Co.

The business's Step Out Buffalo listing says each pizza comes with a side of the shop's own blue cheese for dipping.

A Decade-Long Following

On Facebook, One Pie Pizza describes itself as one of Buffalo's hidden gems and highlights its thick, sweet sauce, fresh dough and crispy crust.

The pizzeria serves its menu from its West Seneca location.