
Mark J. Longo Jr., 36, was arrested Wednesday on felony charges alleging he falsified documents to obtain a $720,000 mortgage, New York State Police said. Longo became widely known online as the owner of Peanut, a squirrel euthanized by state officials in 2024. The mortgage investigation began in December 2024, after Peanut’s seizure and death in the closing days of the 2024 presidential race.
Fraud Investigation Predates Peanut's Death
According to syracuse.com, state police began investigating Longo in December 2024 after receiving information about possible financial irregularities. Investigators allege he used falsified pay stubs, letters and mortgage application documents to obtain a $720,000 residential mortgage in 2023 with two associates. The Chemung County property later became the 311-acre P'Nut's Freedom Farm animal sanctuary, where Longo posted about Peanut and other animals to a social-media following of hundreds of thousands.
Longo was arraigned in Southport Town Court, near the Pennsylvania border, on residential mortgage fraud and second-degree grand larceny charges and pleaded not guilty, New York State Police said. He faces 14 counts in total, including second-degree residential mortgage fraud, attempted second-degree residential mortgage fraud and eight counts of first-degree falsifying business records, the outlet reports. Mortgage fraud is charged as a class C felony under New York Penal Law Article 187; grand larceny and falsifying business records are charged under different Penal Law articles. Longo was released on his own recognizance and is scheduled to return to court on Feb. 4. He did not respond to a request for comment, according to Gothamist's Jon Campbell.
The Squirrel Seizure That Started It All
Longo was not charged in connection with the 2024 seizure of Peanut and Fred, a raccoon that he and his wife, Daniela Bittner, had cared for at their Pine City home and sanctuary. State authorities said Longo did not have the proper license to care for the animals. New York authorities obtained a warrant and seized both animals; Peanut reportedly bit an officer during the encounter. Peanut was euthanized and tested for rabies, with negative results, as was Fred, under the same DEC-directed process, according to the same account.
Rabies testing guidance
The New York State Department of Health says squirrels and other small rodents almost never get rabies, though infection is possible in rare circumstances. Its rabies guidance says determining rabies status for animals other than domesticated animals requires euthanasia and brain testing; the guidance alone does not establish whether it governed Peanut’s case.
The Washington Times reported that the Department of Environmental Conservation said it opened its investigation after receiving multiple reports from the public about potentially unsafe housing of wildlife. Longo and Bittner later sued New York state, Chemung County and several agencies over the seizure and deaths of the animals, seeking damages in an amount the lawsuit did not specify.
Peanut's Death Sparked Threats and Political Firestorm
Peanut’s death prompted a wave of threats against the Department of Environmental Conservation and its officials, including bomb threats, the Syracuse.com report states. At least 10 buildings were temporarily closed, the DEC’s roughly 3,000 employees were allowed to work remotely for a few days, and the agency scaled back some public-facing operations, including deer checks along major thoroughfares.
Peanut became a symbol of government overreach in the aftermath, with political figures including JD Vance and Elon Musk invoking the squirrel's death as an example of government interference, the outlet notes. The case has continued to follow the family: Bittner, who is originally from Germany, was detained by federal immigration authorities last month and now faces possible deportation, according to the Associated Press. Longo has blamed his wife's detention on a paperwork snafu.









