
A church that has stood at the corner of Main and Ward Streets in Paterson since 1852 is being transformed into a performing arts and community space, with crews already at work on the building's exterior. The New Jersey Community Development Corporation is overseeing the conversion of the First Presbyterian Church, which stopped holding worship services in the city years ago.
Workers are using $3 million from a state-awarded American Rescue Plan grant to rehabilitate the building's exterior, including roof repairs and masonry restoration, according to Paterson Press. The outlet describes the overall conversion as a $19 million project, while the NJCDC says it hopes to undertake a comprehensive redevelopment totaling approximately $21 million — the two figures differ, and available reporting does not explain the gap or confirm whether they cover identical scopes.
NJCDC says construction has begun on this initial phase, which it describes as focused on critical work to protect and restore the historic structure. The nonprofit's own account frames the exterior push as Phase I of a larger plan, with the organization adding that the full vision will depend in large part on securing state tax credits and other funding.
Tax Credits Could Unlock the Interior Work
NJCDC has an application pending with the New Jersey Economic Development Corporation for $16 million in tax credits to fund interior renovations, per the same account from Paterson Press. Whether that application will be approved has not been verified; the outlet reported only that the request remains pending. If credits are awarded, NJCDC anticipates beginning Phase II interior redevelopment in mid-2027, continuing for approximately 18 months.
Paterson Press separately reported a goal of starting interior renovations by next summer, with a target opening of January 2029. Those dates are projections tied to the funding outcome rather than confirmed completion dates.
The project already has the approval of the Paterson Historical Preservation Commission, Paterson Press reports. Plans call for a performance space inside the former sanctuary along with a smaller black box theater, an art classroom and exhibition space.
Design Details From the Architecture Firm
Architecture firm CTS Group says it was retained by NJCDC, which it describes as a nonprofit organization serving the Paterson community, to adaptively reuse the building at 320 Main Street. CTS Group's own project description lists a theater and multipurpose room, an art classroom, a warming kitchen, restroom facilities and an interactive exhibit and activity room among the planned spaces.
Paterson Press reported that the building stopped being used for worship about seven years earlier.
A Building With a Long Funding History
The push to save the church predates this year's construction start. The New Jersey Historic Trust awarded a $50,000 grant in 2017 for a preservation plan and followed that with $750,000 in 2020 toward comprehensive rehabilitation, according to Paterson History. A 2019 plan backed by Mayor Andre Sayegh had envisioned the arts center alongside a Great Falls visitor center and a parking garage, but Paterson Press notes that those latter two projects have since stalled.
The church's survival is notable against a backdrop in which other historic Paterson houses of worship have faced the wrecking ball. Earlier this year, the city's zoning board rejected a developer's plan to demolish a 19th-century church and replace it with a four-story building containing 36 apartments and 67 parking spaces, according to Paterson Press. That developer, Lofty Development LLC, had previously sought approval for 42 apartments on the same site before scaling back its proposal.









