
The School District of Philadelphia says it reviewed Green Tree School bus performance after receiving inquiries, but it has not shared the results. The review’s findings therefore remain unavailable in the district’s public account cited here. Separately, two families whose children attend the school described disruptions on routes operated by Zum, which took over the district’s bus service this school year.
A Nearly Three-Hour Wait on Day One
Tymeera Hicks says her son Asir, who attends Green Tree School in West Oak Lane, was scheduled to be picked up for an 8:30 a.m. start on September 3. In an account reported by 6abc, the bus arrived at about 10:40 a.m. and Asir reached school around noon, near dismissal time. Hicks said staff made sure he used the bathroom, gave him his school lunch and put him back on the bus home. She also provided time-stamped videos that she said showed later pickups still taking place around 8:30 a.m. Hicks said, “This is my son's right to be in school.”
The timing problems were not limited to Asir’s route, according to Yook Tiong, a West Philadelphia resident whose 19-year-old son Jose also attends Green Tree School. Tiong told 6abc that Jose arrived late on most days this year and once did not get home until after 5:30 p.m. She said he had never been picked up on time and made it home safely each time.
When transportation is part of special education
Federal regulations define transportation as a related service when it is required to help a child with a disability benefit from special education, according to the eCFR. The regulation’s definition makes that requirement conditional: transportation is a related service when it is needed to support the child’s benefit from special education.
A Tracking App That Went Dark
Tiong told 6abc that the Zum bus-tracking app stopped working, prompting her to call the company for information about her son’s bus. Hicks and Tiong both reported app glitches that improved after they raised questions. The app was designed to provide families with real-time bus notifications, including arrival and pickup and drop-off alerts, according to the Inquirer. 6abc also reported that, on one occasion, a driver told Tiong a fight had broken out on the bus and police were called after the vehicle pulled over.
What the district’s review does—and doesn’t—show
The School District of Philadelphia said it reviewed Green Tree School’s on-time bus performance after receiving inquiries, but did not share the review’s results with 6abc. It said it would continue monitoring service and make improvements as necessary, adding that it was working with Zum on adjustments and valued parents’ concerns. The district’s Board of Education authorized the Zum contract. The district declined to provide additional details about its pre-hire due diligence and declined an on-camera interview, according to 6abc. The public statements described here do not spell out the contract’s service standards, reporting requirements or remedies.
Zum, a Silicon Valley-based company, began providing bus service for the district this school year under a five-year, $483 million contract, replacing the district’s prior transportation arrangement, according to 6abc Philadelphia. The company declined an on-camera interview but said initial school-year challenges were resolved within the first week and that remaining issues involved routing and were being worked out with district leadership. Zum’s website says the company serves 7,500 schools nationwide and reports a 98% average on-time rate; that company-reported figure has not been independently verified for Philadelphia routes.
Not Just a Philadelphia Problem
Similar complaints have followed Zum into other districts this year. In Shawnee Mission, Kansas, parents reported late pickups and tracking-app failures during the first week of school, with one parent telling KCTV5 the app marked his daughter a “no show” even though she was riding the bus. Zum attributed those delays partly to a three-tier bell schedule and 688 students added to routes after the year began, and said it was adding 15 to 20 routes and drivers to catch up; the company reported that 98% of high school buses ran on time one Monday, compared with 85% for elementary schools and 83% for middle schools.
In Johnston, Rhode Island, families described delays, overcrowded buses and missed pickups, along with a lack of communication from Zum, according to WPRI. Superintendent Scott Sutherland ordered Zum to redesign elementary routes there, with changes taking effect August 31. In Rockford, Illinois, families raised concerns about safety, drivers unfamiliar with their routes, and app problems, and the Rockford Public School District 205 said it was working with Zum to fix the issues, per a report from Rockford News First.
Philadelphia's transportation troubles this year weren't limited to Zum's routes, either. Back in July, the district acknowledged that some students in its Extended School Year summer program experienced significant delays on routes operated by a different contractor, First Student, and said it reassigned 10 of that company's routes to address staffing and operational problems, according to the Inquirer.
Options for families and context from an earlier disruption
Pennsylvania Department of Education procedures say that when a parent believes a disagreement concerns the appropriateness of special-education services or the content of special-education documents, the parent may ask the local educational agency to reconvene the IEP team or request due process or mediation. Those procedures describe options for special-education disputes; the district’s public statements cited here do not specify the Zum contract’s service standards, reporting requirements or remedies. A separate July 2026 disruption involved First Student routes for the district’s Extended School Year program, not the current Zum service. The district told the Northeast Times that most routes were operating as scheduled while acknowledging significant delays on some.
How the District Tracks Delays
The School District of Philadelphia says it administers service contracts covering more than 2,100 bus and cab/van routes every day. Its transportation office posts a daily list, updated by each assigned garage, of runs that are canceled or delayed by 30 minutes or more. Parents who want to formally flag a problem can file a Transportation Action Request, which the district says typically takes five to seven school days to process — though it cautions that wait times can run longer at the start of the school year and during other peak periods.









