
Pittsburgh police officers are getting a sizable raise — 19% over four years — under a new labor contract that landed after months of arbitration, just as the city is drafting a 2027 budget that doesn't yet account for the cost. The deal between the City of Pittsburgh and the Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge #1 grants a 3% raise retroactive to January 1, 2026, followed by 4% in 2027, 5% in 2028 and 7% in 2029.
The total increase amounts to 19% in salary by the time the contract expires at the end of 2029, according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. The agreement followed stalled bargaining that ultimately went before a three-member arbitration panel — one neutral arbitrator and two partial arbitrators — after negotiations broke down, the paper reported. The raises apply to uniformed officers, detectives, sergeants and lieutenants represented by the union, according to TribLive.
FOP president Robert Swartzwelder said the contract had been two years in the making, though he was unavailable for an interview Thursday afternoon, according to 90.5 WESA. Mayor Corey O’Connor’s office did not respond to a request for comment by press time, the station reported. Pittsburgh Police Chief Jason Lando, whom O’Connor named to the role earlier this year, was not quoted in the available reporting on the contract itself.
A Budget That Doesn't Yet Add Up the New Costs
The timing is awkward for City Hall. O’Connor's proposed 2027 operating and capital budget totals $872.6 million and relies on $28 million pulled from the city's rainy-day fund to balance the books, per the station's reporting on the mayor's budget rollout earlier this month. The budget does not account for the 3% retroactive salary hike or the 4% raise set to take effect January 1, the same WESA report found, and the Post-Gazette separately confirmed the shortfall in its own coverage of the contract.
TribLive described the mayor's proposed operating budget as $727 million, also noting it would draw more than $28 million from reserves — a different scope of the same spending plan than the $872.6 million operating-and-capital figure cited elsewhere. O’Connor's budget projects that the city will run out of money within five years without major cuts or new revenue, the mayor's office has said. O’Connor himself acknowledged the fiscal squeeze when unveiling the budget, saying that balancing it and replenishing the rainy-day fund “won't be in 2027, and it might not be for a couple of years.”
Notably, the mayor's proposal also reduces the police premium-pay budget by nearly $5.5 million, cutting it from just under $20.5 million to $15 million, the Post-Gazette reported. Under the new contract, officers involuntarily assigned to special-event staffing will see higher compensation than before, including triple time for certain holiday schedule changes — a step up from previous contracts, which limited forced special-event staffing pay to the standard overtime rate of time and a half.
City Council's Take: Pay Up to Keep Officers
Anthony Coghill, chair of the city council's public safety committee, said the contract could help retain police officers and described it overall as not a bad thing, since it might encourage officers to stay in the city rather than leave for better-paying jobs elsewhere. He said Pittsburgh needs salaries that keep up with suburban pay, pointing to the fact that many officers have already departed for higher-paying positions outside the city.
Coghill acknowledged the raises will affect the overall budget and said they will deepen the city's financial shortfall, requiring additional spending. He added that the city had no real choice but to accept the arbitration outcome and will need to find a way to pay for it, though he said he could not estimate the total cost of the raises.
Pittsburgh's Ongoing Retention Struggle
The new contract follows years of documented staffing strain inside the department. Pittsburgh police recorded 105 retirements and resignations in 2024, the highest annual total in at least a decade, according to Police1. The city's staffing goal in its 2025 budget was set at 800 officers, down from 850 budgeted in 2024 and 900 in 2023, per WESA's earlier reporting on recruitment efforts.
That struggle isn't unique to Pittsburgh. An International Association of Chiefs of Police survey cited in that same WESA report found more than 70% of over 1,100 responding departments said recruitment had grown harder than it was five years earlier. University of Pittsburgh professor David Harris told the station that officers could earn $20,000 to $30,000 more simply by moving to another department in the region — a gap city leaders hope the new raises will help close.
Pittsburgh's previous FOP contract, negotiated under former Mayor Ed Gainey, was completed without arbitration and lasted three years, providing a 9% pay hike in its first year followed by 3% increases in each of the following two years, according to WTAE. That earlier deal took effect immediately and ran through 2025. Nonunion city workers, meanwhile, are expected to receive a 3% pay bump in the 2027 budget, typically the city's standard annual cost-of-living adjustment, TribLive reported.









