Columbus/ Politics & Govt

PJM Review of Cardinal Unit Continues as Ohio Bill Targets Settlement Closures

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
PJM Review of Cardinal Unit Continues as Ohio Bill Targets Settlement ClosuresSource: Riis2602 / Wikimedia Commons

PJM Interconnection’s reliability review of the Cardinal plant’s 620-megawatt Unit 3 is still underway. The regional grid operator’s September 2026 update lists January 1, 2029, as the requested deactivation date. PJM assesses whether a proposed shutdown date could create reliability problems; it does not approve or reject plant deactivations, according to its generation deactivation update.

The settlement dispute is distinct from PJM’s technical review. Columbus Underground reported that on March 6, PJM operations executive Michael Bryson wrote to Buckeye Power, citing the federal administration’s declared grid emergency and urging the company to seek a Sierra Club waiver or a court ruling invalidating the settlement.

The draft would cover more than the Cardinal settlement

The draft bill obtained by Canary Media would prevent a coal plant from closing when a settlement requires its shutdown. As described by Columbus Underground, its provisions cover past and future settlements arising from state-court or regulatory proceedings, but not agreements reached in federal court. The outlet reported that the restriction could reduce community and environmental groups’ leverage in some disputes over nuisance claims or permit violations.

The Cardinal closure pledge originated in a 2015 settlement between the Sierra Club and AEP’s Ohio utility, which then owned part of the plant. The agreement also required other measures. The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio approved it in March 2016, Columbus Underground reported. Buckeye Power took on AEP’s obligations for Cardinal after buying the plant in 2022.

Buckeye Power backs the draft and intends to submit testimony after it is introduced, according to Columbus Underground. The company says the proposal would help maintain reliable, affordable electricity and keep generation available. If enacted as drafted, it could allow the unit to remain open despite the settlement’s closure pledge.

The agreement’s status is disputed

The settlement’s enforceability is also contested. Columbus Underground reported that in March Sarah Parrot, a federal energy advocate at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, told Buckeye Power that the commission would not enforce the agreement because regulators had not approved it. That position appears at odds with the commission’s reported March 2016 approval.

Neil Waggoner, the Sierra Club’s Midwest Beyond Coal coordinator, has said the bill would undo Buckeye Power’s settlement obligation and questioned its constitutionality, according to Columbus Underground. Article II, Section 28 of the Ohio Constitution bars retroactive laws and laws impairing contractual obligations, but its text alone does not determine how a court would assess this proposal. Waggoner has also argued that existing procedures can determine whether technical reasons require a plant to keep operating. The constitutional text is available at Article II, Section 28.

A past ruling offers limited guidance

In a 2016 case involving the Toledo City School District Board of Education, the Supreme Court of Ohio held that the retroactivity clause does not prohibit retroactive laws that negatively affect state subdivisions. That ruling concerned government entities and does not resolve how Article II, Section 28 applies to Buckeye Power’s settlement, according to the Supreme Court of Ohio.

Lawmakers face a year-end deadline

The proposal’s legislative path remains uncertain. Democratic Rep. Tristan Rader, the House Energy Committee’s ranking minority member, opposes it. Columbus Underground reported that Rader said lawmakers could consider the draft on its own or attach it to legislation already further along. The session ends December 31. Amy Acton is scheduled to take office in January, when Republicans will no longer hold a House supermajority.