Hampton Roads/ Politics & Govt

Portsmouth Seeks Power to Yank Nightclub Permits as Guava Sues City

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Portsmouth Seeks Power to Yank Nightclub Permits as Guava Sues CityAfton Green — Reported Residential Noise Complaints
Google Street View

Portsmouth city leaders are pushing Virginia lawmakers for more muscle over who can run a bar, restaurant or nightclub with late-night entertainment — and the fight is already playing out in court. One business in the crosshairs, Guava, is suing the city after city staff recommended revoking its permit. City Council had not acted on that recommendation before a judge temporarily blocked the city from acting while the case unfolds.

Portsmouth City Council wants the same rights the cities of Hampton and Norfolk have, according to WAVY.com. In those cities, a business's use permit expires the moment ownership changes, forcing a new operator to go back before city council for a fresh vote rather than simply inheriting the old approval. In most of Virginia, by contrast, a use permit stays in effect indefinitely as long as the property keeps the same permitted use, regardless of who owns or runs the business.

Portsmouth council members raised the issue with state legislators last week, according to the same report. Mayor Shannon Glover said the city needs tools to hold people accountable in late-night entertainment environments. Glover has previously pointed to Norfolk's own 2021-2022 crackdown as part of what pushed some nightclub operators toward Portsmouth in the first place.

Neighbors Describe Noise and Violence Near Williams Court II

The push for new authority comes as residents of the Afton Green development, built on the grounds of the former Cradock High School, have complained about the noise and, at times, violent incidents they say are coming late in the night from businesses at the nearby Williams Court II shopping center along George Washington Highway. That shopping center sits at the center of the current dispute between the city and Guava.

Portsmouth City Attorney Derek Challenger told council the entertainment use permit in question was approved 25 years ago, when houses were not yet on the neighboring property — a gap he says has left the city with limited recourse as the surrounding area has grown residential. Challenger wants to prevent a business from changing hands while keeping the same use permit intact, and Vice Mayor Bill Moody echoed that view, saying the permit should attach to the operator rather than transfer to another owner running the same type of business.

Guava's Permit Fight Lands in Court

In September, city staff recommended that Guava have its permit revoked, citing alleged violations of permit conditions and reported violence, per the city. Before council could act, a Portsmouth Circuit Court judge, Michael Massie, issued a temporary injunction prohibiting the council from moving on Guava's permit while litigation proceeds. During a council discussion of the broader permit issue, Challenger halted further conversation because of the ongoing legal action.

A Bill Stalled Once Already

This is not Portsmouth's first attempt to get this authority. Legislation that would have made the change stalled in the General Assembly last year, and state Sens. Louise Lucas and Emily Jordan and Del. Cliff Hayes were present at the recent meeting with Portsmouth council members, though the lawmakers did not explain why the earlier bill stalled and did not return calls seeking comment, per WAVY's report.

A newer measure appears to have moved further. The County, Cities and Towns Subcommittee voted 8-0 to report House Bill 679, a measure from Delegate Hayes that would add Portsmouth to the list of localities with an established review process for certain zoning approvals when ownership or management changes, according to Citizen Portal. City officials and police testified that the change fills enforcement gaps and can aid public-safety responses, that report noted. The bill's text, as posted by the Virginia General Assembly, would let Hampton, Norfolk and Portsmouth impose a condition on certain alcohol-related special exceptions or use permits so they automatically expire upon changes in ownership, possession, operation or management.

The underlying authority already on the books for Hampton and Norfolk is laid out in the Code of Virginia, which allows the governing body or board of zoning appeals in those cities to attach a condition letting certain alcohol-related permits expire automatically after a change in ownership, possession, facility operation or management, or after a set period of time.

Hampton Offers a Preview of What Stricter Rules Look Like

Hampton's own experience shows what added leverage over nightlife permits can mean in practice. The city has proposed requiring security — state-certified through the Department of Criminal Justice Services, with at least one officer per 100 indoor patrons and at least two more for exterior areas and parking lots — for businesses that serve alcohol, operate past 11 p.m., host at least 100 people and offer live entertainment, according to The Virginian-Pilot. Those proposed requirements would apply only to new businesses, so long as they keep their permits, the outlet reported.

Hampton has already used its existing authority to act. The city revoked permits for three late-night businesses within a roughly eight-month span following several shootings and police calls for other violent incidents, per the same Virginian-Pilot report. Hampton's Planning Commission also voted in May to recommend that City Council revoke the special use permit of Southern Comfort Restaurant & Lounge, a move that, according to WTKR, would reduce the hours the business can stay open if council follows through.

For Portsmouth, the comparison underscores what's at stake as the Guava case winds through court and the General Assembly weighs House Bill 679. Whether the bill ultimately becomes law, and how the pending litigation over Guava's permit is resolved, remain open questions as both tracks continue to move forward.