New York City/ Food & Drinks

Prince St. Pizza Picks Eatontown for First New Jersey Shop, Opening Spring 2027

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Prince St. Pizza Picks Eatontown for First New Jersey Shop, Opening Spring 202727 Prince St — Founding Neighborhood and Brand Origin
Google Street View

Prince St. Pizza is finally coming to New Jersey. The Nolita-born pizzeria plans to open its first restaurant in the state at 180 Route 35 in Eatontown in spring 2027, landing inside the Monmouth Square development near the junction of Routes 35 and 36.

The planned restaurant spans 2,528 square feet, according to RestaurantNews.com, which reports the chain will announce grand-opening details and operating hours at a later date. The Eatontown shop will mark Prince St. Pizza's third location in the tri-state area once it opens.

Monmouth Square itself is a major undertaking — a redevelopment of the former Monmouth Mall site that Kushner Companies has described as transforming the property into an open-air town center. Back in March 2025, Kushner confirmed that Prince Street Pizza was among the tenants signed for the project, according to re-nj.com. The outlet reported the overall project carries a roughly $500 million price tag and is envisioned as a town center blending shopping, dining, medical offices, an expansive public green, pedestrian pathways and 1,000 luxury apartments.

What's on the Menu for Eatontown

Prince St. Pizza built its name on Sicilian-style square pies and pepperoni-loaded slices, along with original Neapolitan-style pizzas, and the Eatontown location is expected to offer the full lineup — including the Spicy Spring, classic pies, salads and desserts. The company makes its signature sauces from scratch daily and filters its dough water to mirror New York City's water, following recipes passed down through generations of the Morano family.

CEO Lawrence Longo said the company will bring signature pies, hospitality and room for families and friends to Eatontown, adding that Prince St. Pizza looks forward to introducing itself and joining the community there.

A Fast-Growing Pizza Chain

Founded in New York City's Nolita neighborhood in 2012, Prince St. Pizza has expanded into markets including Las Vegas, Chicago, Los Angeles, Dallas, Nashville and Miami, according to pizzamarketplace.com. The chain also has a presence in Toronto, Tempe and San Diego, and currently operates 21 locations across the U.S.

Eatontown isn't the only spot getting a new Prince St. Pizza next spring. The chain also plans to open its second Toronto restaurant in spring 2027, a 2,500-square-foot shop at 2472 Yonge Street, according to a separate report from pizzamarketplace.com.

For a glimpse of what an opening day might look like, Prince St. Pizza's recent debut in Baton Rouge offers a comparison. The chain opened its first Louisiana location along Siegen Lane at 11 a.m. on a Friday, offering a free slice to the first 50 people in line, according to wbrz.com. That Baton Rouge menu included the Spicy Spring, The Naughty Pie, classic New York rounds, Caesar and Italian chopped salads, smoked mozzarella sticks and desserts — a lineup Eatontown diners may eventually recognize once their own location opens.

Prince St. Pizza follows a simple philosophy guiding its menu development: if you can put it on pasta, you can put it on pizza. Whether that extends to whatever toppings eventually land on the Eatontown menu remains to be seen, as the company has not yet released further specifics beyond its initial announcement.