New York City/ Sports

Red Bulls-Club América Friendly Erupts Into Brawl, Red Cards Fly at Harrison Stadium

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 15, 2026
Red Bulls-Club América Friendly Erupts Into Brawl, Red Cards Fly at Harrison StadiumSports Illustrated Stadium — Venue Of Friendly Match Brawl
Google Street View

New York’s 1-0 win over Club América was overshadowed by a late brawl at Sports Illustrated Stadium on Saturday night. Accounts agree that the clash involved players from both teams, but they differ on the flashpoint and on how many players were sent off. Fans also threw objects onto the field, according to match reports.

A Late Flashpoint Turns Physical

Reports differ on both the timing and the trigger. According to The Athletic, the brawl began with six minutes remaining after a foul near the touchline. USA Today places the flashpoint in the 85th minute, describing a foul near the end line, while El Imparcial puts it closer to the 84th minute and links it to a disputed ball battle between Miguel Borja and a Red Bulls player. The accounts describe a melee involving punches, kicks, pushing and wrestling; USA Today also reported that fans threw objects onto the field.

Stadium Rules on Throwing Objects

According to the New York Red Bulls’ published Sports Illustrated Stadium policies, the MLS Fan Code of Conduct prohibits throwing objects. Violations may lead to penalties including ejection without a refund or loss of ticket privileges.

Buried in the disorder was an actual goal. Nehuén Benedetti had given New York the lead in the 58th minute, a strike that stood up as the match winner once the dust settled, per El Imparcial's account of the contest at Sports Illustrated Stadium.

Red Card Counts Don't Match Up

Published accounts do not agree on the number of dismissals. USA Today, citing Sofascore, counted five red cards: Ronald Donkor and Benedetti for New York, and Emilio Lara, Ramón Juárez and Dagoberto Espinoza for América. It said it was unclear whether Andy Rojas was also ejected. The Athletic lists the same five players as sent off.

Other outlets reported different totals. Infobae counted six, adding Rojas to New York’s list alongside Benedetti and Donkor, while naming the same three América players. El Heraldo de México reported eight expulsions: Espinoza, Lara, Valle and Juárez for América, and Bazán, Marshall-Rutty, Mosquera and Benedetti for New York. No official match report, referee statement or club statement has surfaced to resolve the conflicting accounts.

Bradley Chalks It Up to Emotion

Speaking to USA Today, Red Bulls head coach Michael Bradley said his team had been excited to play Club América and described the late flare-up as emotion spilling over. He added that football is emotional and that players want to compete and win regardless of how a match is labeled.

The friendly came at a flat moment for New York, which finished 10th in the Eastern Conference during the MLS regular season and missed the playoffs, wrapping its campaign without a postseason berth the weekend before the brawl. Club América, by contrast, arrived with plenty on the line of its own — the club sat second in Liga MX with 30 points and one match remaining in its Apertura season, a game against Tigres UANL still to come, according to Infobae.