
Paola Sanchez says she has decided to shut down "Are We Dating the Same Guy?", the private Facebook network she started in New York City around 2022. The reason she has given is recent issues. She has not said what they are.
News 5 Cleveland reported that Sanchez said recent issues had led her to shut down all of the groups, and quoted her warning to the Cleveland, Akron and Canton page: "With the attacks continuing to happen, I cannot guarantee that this group will still be here tomorrow." The organization describes the network as spanning more than 250 cities and 10 million members, according to an account of the litigation around the pages. The New York Post reported Nov. 14 that she had announced the wind-down earlier this fall.
A Warning List, City by City
They are private, location-based Facebook pages where women share men's dating profiles and information, including warnings about infidelity or abuse. A member posts a photo of a potential date and asks whether anyone else has seen cheating or another red flag. The Post has described the use in plainer terms: women catching cheating boyfriends, flagging alleged abusers and warning one another about dates that looked dangerous.
Scale is not theoretical. One Hampton Roads group has been reported to serve nearly 80,000 members, a single metro area inside a network that describes its own reach in the millions.
Sanchez launched the original New York City group in spring 2022. That year already had a public version of the same comparison. Multiple New York women alleged they had dated, and been ghosted by, the same furniture designer, in what became known as the West Elm Caleb saga. Inside a New York Facebook group, women comparing notes also identified a married man, later called Long Island Kevin, whose alleged dating encounters did not line up with the marriage.
The Washington Post, writing about the groups in 2024, described them as offering intel while upending lives. Its account included Jocelyn, a woman in her 30s in the Pacific Northwest, who could not shake the feeling that an abusive partner's conduct was her fault. Her therapist suggested she seek out other women who had experienced something similar.
Alleged Deletes and a Local Pause
News 5 reported that at least 10 other "Are We Dating the Same Guy?" pages had allegedly been deleted by Facebook without warning. Administrators have said the network has faced threats, lawsuits and complaints to Facebook from some of the men posted about. Sanchez's line to the Cleveland-area group made the local stakes plain. If the attacks continued, she would not promise the page would still be there the next day.
The same reporting described a narrower interruption on that page. Posting paused in March. On June 18, moderators allowed it again after new rules were added. News 5 also reported that Sanchez promised a more detailed explanation later. A pause, a rewrite of the rules and a founder who would not guarantee the next day are already a lot of uncertainty for one regional page.
A Case That Stopped at Opinion
The lawsuits are specific. In 2024, Nikko D'Ambrosio sued Sanchez, Meta and dozens of others after a woman described him as clingy and accused him of flaunting wealth and boasting about his bad side. Founder, platform and a long list of other defendants landed in the same complaint.
On May 13, 2025, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois dismissed his second amended complaint with prejudice, so that complaint could not be filed again. The opinion said the descriptions of his dating behavior were subjective opinions, not verifiable facts. The court also said it did not need to decide whether Section 230 applied. That statute often limits lawsuits against websites over what users post. Because the court stopped at opinion, it never had to sort out whether Meta, Sanchez or the women who posted would have been covered.
D'Ambrosio lost an appeal in May 2026. The federal answer to this complaint is the dismissal.
From a Group Post to a Guilty Plea
Some posts have sat next to criminal cases. West Linn, Oregon, police began investigating Nicholas Michael Donohue in May 2024 after reports of concerning behavior on dating apps and a post about him in an "Are We Dating the Same Guy?" group. He pleaded guilty to coercion and domestic violence assault charges. On Nov. 4 he was sentenced to 70 days in jail and three years of probation.
The network has claimed that members helped expose Army Maj. Jonathan Batt. The New York Post reported that he was sentenced in 2025 to 53 years in prison for raping and assaulting multiple women. In Donohue's case, the path on the record is narrower: app reports, a group post, a police investigation, a guilty plea, then 70 days and three years of probation.
Comparisons, Support and Blowback
The Post's account of ordinary use is a series of comparisons. Cris, 35, from New York City, found that her ex had allegedly been involved with at least seven other women during their relationship. Alissa Fitzgerald said posts suggested a Welsh tech worker she dated was seeing at least 12 other women, and that 12 was too many. She has also said the groups offered women connection and resources and helped them check men's intentions.
Fitzgerald described a harder return as well. A man she posted about in Seattle, she said, accused her of doxxing him after a screenshot leaked and sent threatening messages from a burner number. Michele Smith shared a sexual-assault experience in a group in 2022. Support and praise from other women for coming forward, she said, were phenomenal.
The comparisons did not stay on Facebook. In 2023, Mikayla Miedzianowski went viral on TikTok after she said a group in Florida showed that her boyfriend had cheated. The video drew millions of views. Jene Sena has argued that the same setup can be unfair to men, because a jilted woman might post someone vindictively.
Sanchez has said she will explain the issues when she has the energy, and she has promised details on the network's future. About four and a half years after the first New York City group, members have the decision. The reason is the part she has not given them yet.









