Los Angeles/ Crime & Emergencies

Santa Monica Judge Keeps Jamie McCourt's Lawyer on Case Days Before Trial

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Santa Monica Judge Keeps Jamie McCourt's Lawyer on Case Days Before TrialSource: Another Believer / Wikimedia Commons

A Santa Monica judge has refused to remove one of Jamie McCourt's attorneys from a long-running lawsuit brought by her former head of security, clearing the way for a trial scheduled to begin next Monday. Judge Mark H. Epstein ruled Monday that attorney Cris Armenta can keep representing McCourt, the 72-year-old former wife of former Los Angeles Dodgers owner Frank McCourt, despite claims from plaintiff Jeff Fuller that Armenta improperly obtained confidential information.

Judge Questions, But Doesn't Punish, Disputed Phone Call

Fuller had asked the court to disqualify Armenta, arguing that conversations she had with one of his former lawyers revealed privileged or at least confidential information, according to MyNewsLA.com. Epstein did not simply wave off the concern. He wrote that he was unsure whether it was an ethics breach for Armenta to listen to the conversation rather than hang up, the outlet reported.

Still, the judge suggested a cleaner path existed. If Armenta knew Fuller's former lawyer was speaking without authorization, Epstein wrote, the better course would have been to tell that lawyer to stop talking if anything material was being revealed. Short of finding a clear ethics violation, the judge declined to strip McCourt of her counsel so close to trial, which is scheduled for Nov. 23 under the same report.

Removing a lawyer can disrupt a case and force a client to find new counsel, but that concern is weighed against protecting confidential information and the integrity of court proceedings. In a 2025 decision, a California appellate court recognized that the burden of replacing counsel may be outweighed by the court’s duty to preserve the integrity of the judicial process. That balance helps explain why a disqualification request can turn on more than whether a judge has concerns about an attorney’s conduct.

California’s professional-conduct rules bar a lawyer from communicating about a case with someone the lawyer knows is represented by another lawyer, absent that lawyer’s consent. The rule addresses contact with a represented person; the dispute here, as described by the judge, centered on Armenta listening to a conversation with Fuller’s former lawyer and what confidential information it revealed. California Rule of Professional Conduct 4.2 provides that broader backdrop but does not, by itself, resolve the issue raised in Fuller’s motion.

A Breakup Over Property, Not Just Personnel

The underlying case traces back to Fuller's claim that he's owed a split of property after McCourt allegedly breached their agreement in 2021. Fuller accused McCourt of wrongfully cutting him out of his share of millions the two accumulated during what he describes as a longtime business partnership, including Good Shepard Motorsports LLC, a motorsports racing company the pair formed in 2012 that participated in professional off-road races.

McCourt's attorneys see it very differently. According to their 2021 court papers, no partnership ever existed between Fuller and McCourt, and her lawyers have called his contrary claims a complete fabrication. The dossier does not resolve which version is accurate — only that the two sides remain squarely at odds as the case heads toward trial.

From Security Chief to Romantic Partner to Litigant

The relationship's origins stretch back nearly two decades. Jamie and Frank McCourt, who bought the Dodgers for $400 million in 2004, appointed Fuller to lead their family security in 2006. By April 2008, McCourt and Fuller had begun a romantic dating relationship, the lawsuit states, describing Fuller as a respected security analyst, consultant and strategist.

Both McCourt and Fuller lost their jobs in 2009 over the relationship — Frank McCourt fired Jamie from her Dodgers executive duties, while Fuller was stripped of his own job, each cited for having an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate or superior. Jamie McCourt filed for divorce that same year. Per the lawsuit, McCourt later promised Fuller they would split everything equally if their partnership ended, and told him he would never have to worry about money again if he dedicated his life to her.

Diplomacy, Hollywood Cameos and a Falling-Out

The years that followed included some unusual detours tied to the alleged partnership. Fuller invented the persona Robert Acer in 2012, and Good Shepard Motorsports began the Robert Acer Project, described as a humanitarian mission to aid, educate, feed and support children of Mexico. The lawsuit also recounts McCourt and Fuller visiting Rome to see actor Will Ferrell during filming of Zoolander 2.

When Donald Trump appointed McCourt ambassador to France and Monaco in 2017, Fuller managed the couple's partnership interests while traveling between the United States and Paris, per the suit. McCourt ended her ambassadorship in 2021. That same February, she allegedly ended her business partnership with Fuller through an intermediary, and the following month, armed guards ordered Fuller off a Napa property, according to the lawsuit's account.

High-Profile Counsel on Both Sides

Armenta isn't McCourt's only notable attorney. Alex Spiro, who also represents McCourt, previously defended actor Alec Baldwin against criminal charges tied to the fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on the New Mexico set of Rust — charges a judge dismissed in 2024. McCourt's legal team has described Fuller as a con artist claiming entitlement to half of his wealthy former companion's assets, a characterization Fuller disputes through his own allegations of breach of contract.

The litigation has already stretched across several years of court filings. A 2021 ruling allowed Fuller to move forward with his allegations of breach of contract, the same outlet previously reported. With Epstein's disqualification ruling now behind them, both sides are set to face off at trial next Monday — though what the court ultimately decides about the alleged partnership, and who owes what to whom, remains to be seen.