Greater Birmingham/ Crime & Emergencies

Saraland Man Acquitted in Death of Mama Tot's Teen Son After 90-Minute Jury Deliberation

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Saraland Man Acquitted in Death of Mama Tot's Teen Son After 90-Minute Jury DeliberationE. Prichard Ave. — Prichard Street Scene
Google Street View

A Mobile County jury needed only about an hour and a half to find Reuben Thomas Gulley not guilty of murder on Friday, clearing him in the June 2022 shooting death of 18-year-old Randon Lee, the son of TikTok personality Ophelia “Mama Tot” Nichols. Prosecutors had alleged that Gulley, now 25, shot Lee at a Prichard gas station during a marijuana deal gone wrong, while Gulley testified he fired only after Lee shot at him first.

A Drug Deal That Turned Deadly

According to fox10tv.com, prosecutors alleged that Gulley shot Lee at the Prichard gas station in June 2022 while trying to buy marijuana from him. Gulley testified he had arranged to pay $300 for two ounces of marijuana from Lee, and he told jurors he shot Lee during the drug transaction after Lee fired a shot at him first, a claim reported by the New York Post. Gulley also claimed self-defense on the stand, maintaining that Lee pulled a gun before Gulley returned fire.

Per the Post's reporting, security footage captured Gulley running to a car with a gun after Lee drove away, but the footage did not show the shooting itself. Prosecutors argued Gulley shot Lee in order to avoid paying for the drugs, while Gulley testified he had pulled out fifteen $20 bills to pay for the marijuana.

Defense Zeroed In On Police Missteps

Gulley's defense argued that Prichard police did not properly investigate the case, secure the crime scene, or properly interview witnesses, according to wkrg.com. The same reporting notes that Gulley's attorney, Chase Dearman, accused detectives of failing to follow up on leads and failing to explain the bullet evidence in the case. Dearman told WALA he was relieved by the acquittal.

One flashpoint centered on a shell casing: Lee's stepfather found the casing in Lee's car after investigators arranged for the family to take possession of the vehicle, and defense attorney Chase Dearman said the casing had never been examined, per the station's report. The defense also confronted the case's initial lead detective, Jason Hadaway, about his own perjury conviction during the trial — a jury found Hadaway guilty of third-degree perjury in 2025, and he had appealed his 2024 conviction.

Policing Upheaval in Prichard

The investigation's credibility problems unfolded against the backdrop of a broader shakeup in Prichard's law enforcement. After multiple city officers were arrested, the Mobile County Sheriff's Office took over policing duties in the city, with Prichard signing a one-year agreement with the Sheriff's Office, the same report notes. Mobile County Chief Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Susman said prosecutors believed in their case despite the investigation's problems, but acknowledged that issues with the Prichard Police Department appeared to distract jurors, according to the Post. Susman added that prosecutors hoped jurors in future proceedings would focus on the rest of the evidence.

A Mother's Reaction

Nichols, who has more than 12 million TikTok followers under the Mama Tot name, said she did not know how or why the jurors reached their decision, per the Post's reporting. She said her husband broke down in tears when the jury foreman announced the verdict, noting he had cried only about three times during their 20-year marriage before that moment in court. Nichols also said her daughter cried after the verdict was read.

Gulley is not entirely free of legal exposure from the case. His bond has been reinstated on separate pending charges of first-degree unlawful possession of marijuana and unlawful possession of a controlled substance, according to wkrg.com's reporting. At trial, Gulley's defense argued he acted in self-defense.