
Sarasota's City Commission voted 3-2 Monday to reject an agreement that would have spent at least $8 million on 160 public parking spaces in a garage connected to the McCown Towers housing expansion in the Rosemary District.
Monday's vote did not decide the development application, and it did not produce a garage the city would own. The rejected deal was a decades-long sublease Sarasota would have financed without owning, after the estimated cost of that borrowing had already moved up. Sarasota Magazine reported the vote and the terms. ABC7 reported that the affordable-housing project will still move forward without the additional public parking, and that other options are still being explored.
A Lease The City Would Not Own
Mayor Kathy Kelley Ohlrich, Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch and Commissioner Flo Entler voted to reject the agreement with the Sarasota Housing Authority. Commissioners Kyle Battie and Liz Alpert opposed rejecting it.
The redevelopment sits near Boulevard of the Arts and North Cocoanut Avenue. It includes 96 affordable apartments for older adults, retail space and a 343-space parking structure. One hundred sixty of those spaces would have been public. The rest were reserved for residents, commercial tenants and others associated with the development.
In October, the housing authority told Sarasota that the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development would not permit condominium-style ownership of the city's portion of the garage. The city would have received a sublease to operate the 160 spaces for 50 to 65 years. The borrowing to pay for that arrangement was not expected until 2027, so the city would have been signing on for a half-century of operating leased stalls before it had even financed them.
Ohlrich said she initially supported the proposal but became uncomfortable with its changing terms and the financial exposure. Ahearn-Koch said the financial uncertainties were too significant amid potential changes to city property-tax revenue. Entler said there were too many unknowns for her to commit the city.
Battie said the area needs parking that would also serve the bay and future development. Alpert said postponing a parking investment could leave the city spending millions more on the same problem.
The Drawings Did Not Hold Still
The parking arrangement had been discussed for more than a year. The garage in those discussions did not keep a stable shape.
On Jan. 8, commissioners voted 4-1 to spend an estimated $200,000 designing a garage with one floor of resident parking and two floors offering 160 public spaces, WSLR reported. Ahearn-Koch objected. Interim City Manager David Bullock's rough estimate put the garage project's total cost near $12 million.
A Jan. 21 update in the housing authority's Jan. 28 board packet discussed reducing the structure from five decks to four. That version put residents on floors 1 and 2 and the city on floors 3 and 4, with free overflow parking for residents. It was a different stack than the three-level design the commission had just agreed to draw.
In April, the Sarasota Observer reported that the commission declined to add $4 million to $8 million already pledged for public parking. Finance Director Kelly Strickland estimated that interest on $8 million in parking bonds would bring the city's cost to $12 million over 20 years of debt service. Strickland was pricing the city's borrowing. Bullock had roughly priced the garage. The numbers landed near each other. They were not the same bill, and Monday's vote was on the agreement itself.
Borrowing As A Tenant
Financial advisers anticipated taxable rather than tax-exempt borrowing because the city would lease the spaces. Under the proposed lease, the estimated interest rate rose from 4.75 percent to roughly 6 percent. The estimated total repayment rose from $12.72 million to $13.81 million, an increase of $1.09 million under the revised assumptions.
The agreement would have required the city to cover approximately 46.65 percent of shared garage maintenance and operating expenses, plus the cost of operating its public parking program. After a specified period, the housing authority would have received a share of net parking cash flow. Sarasota would have borrowed as a tenant, paid nearly half the shared upkeep, and then split the net with the agency holding the lease.
Walker Consultants examined a districtwide paid-parking program in a September study covering 524 existing on-street spaces, 39 public off-street spaces and the proposed garage. Proposed rates were $1.50 an hour for street parking and $1 an hour in the garage and the existing public lot.
Walker projected approximately $1.52 million in annual revenue. A preliminary model showed approximately $264,000 remaining annually after operating expenses and debt payments. The consultants cautioned that the revenue projections required further verification before they could support a financing commitment. That leftover was a model result, not money in hand.
A city memorandum said businesses at a March meeting supported paid parking in exchange for additional spaces. Residents supported expanding parking opportunities and held mixed opinions about charging. District businesses and the Rosemary District Association had advocated for the added public spaces. The revenue case needed a fee. The people who would pay it had not spoken with one voice.
Peak Season And A 216-Space Gap
The Rosemary District has a longstanding shortage of convenient public parking. The Rosemary Residential Overlay District encouraged denser development with reduced parking requirements, which let projects add density while providing fewer spaces of their own. Ahearn-Koch said that reduction foreseeably contributed to the shortage the city was now being asked to relieve.
A study provided by the housing authority, reported in January, counted 555 on-street spaces. Use was estimated at about 85 percent during peak season and 60 percent in the off-season. At those rates, peak season would leave roughly 80 of the on-street spaces open, and the off-season about 220. The study still said 216 additional spaces were needed. The same account said a garage could add 80 to 160 public spaces along with residential parking.
The rejected deal's 160 public stalls were the top of that range, and short of 216. Peak use and off-season use were far enough apart that the shortage the study described was not a flat, every-month condition. Any bond repayment would have been a year-round cost. Inside the proposed 343-space structure, the stalls outside the public 160 were reserved for residents, commercial tenants and others associated with the development. The district argument was for the public share. That is the share the commission declined to lease.
Apartments Advance, Stalls Do Not
Rejecting the parking agreement does not reject the development application. That application remains subject to its own approval process. City Manager Karie Friling said the housing authority planned to redesign the garage and proceed without city financial participation.
The housing authority has described the McCown project as adding 96 affordable senior housing apartments. In May, the Observer reported that funding for the senior housing project remained one step short. Fortis Development is pursuing the housing authority's redevelopment, and the latest proposal pairs those 96 apartments with a mixed-use building.
Friling said city staff would continue exploring other ways to add public parking in the Rosemary District. The options include acquiring property for a city-owned garage or pursuing another partnership. A garage the city owned would answer the objection about leasing rather than owning. It would not answer the objection about cost. Either path needs more time, more funding and another negotiation. The 160 spaces connected to McCown Towers are no longer the city's route to a public stall in that building.









