Western New York/ Real Estate & Development

Savarino Sues NFTA After DL&W Terminal Development Deal Ends

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Savarino Sues NFTA After DL&W Terminal Development Deal EndsSource: Ammodramus / Wikimedia Commons

Samuel Savarino wants a court to decide that his shot at Buffalo's DL&W Terminal is not over. He sued the Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority in New York State Supreme Court, alleging the agency improperly and illegally ended his redevelopment contract.

As The Buffalo News reported, the fight is over the historic terminal's unfinished commercial future, not the trains already running through it. Savarino says he invested well over $1 million in predevelopment work. The NFTA's reported position is that he never produced a plan the public agency could actually build on.

A Dollar a Year for a Public Building

The paper trail is where the deal gets strange. Savarino proposed a $1-a-year lease for 20 years, with three 10-year extensions.

The proposed lease terms became a point of contention. A dollar a year is a lovely number, but the parties did not reach an agreement.

The NFTA later criticized Savarino's business plan, saying it was not viable.

Five Years, Then a Termination Letter

Savarino was the only developer to respond to a 2019 solicitation. The pre-development agreement was signed in July 2020.

Savarino says the parties worked on the project for “7+ years” and maintains that he has development rights. He also says he worked with the NFTA to obtain $30 million. The NFTA has invested $57 million in the building.

When the split came is itself in dispute. Buffalo Rising, recounting the plaintiffs' case, says the NFTA purported to terminate the pre-development agreement in November 2025. Savarino calls the grounds factually and legally unfounded. He says the contract's notice-and-cure protections were not honored. The plaintiffs want a declaration that the agreement remains in full force and effect.

Buffalo Business First reported the authority's shorter version: Savarino was pulled after failing to provide a viable business plan. The NFTA said Savarino failed to provide a viable business plan.

What Actually Opened

While the lawyers argue over paper, part of the building is already in public use. BTPM reported that the terminal reopened as a Metro station in 2025, and that a new 55,000-square-foot DL&W Sky Deck was set to open to the public on the first Saturday of October 2026. WBEN covered the Thursday ribbon-cutting. BTPM reported that the second level is about 125,000 square feet.

Savarino's team has shared renderings of the historic railroad station's second floor as a vast public market. The station and the deck are the pieces a rider can see. The market is still a rendering.

The NFTA's executive director said a new RFP was expected for second-level development.

Glass, and a Court With No Ruling

One would-be tenant has not waited for the lawyers to finish. The developers told Buffalo Rising that their plan includes Buffalo Electric Glass. Separately, The Buffalo News reported that a nonprofit glassmaking venture hoping to anchor the second level is pushing ahead despite the fight between the developer it had been working with and the building's owner.

Savarino alleges the NFTA failed to cooperate in good faith. Those are allegations.

The practical split is already visible on the waterfront. Riders have a station and a sky deck. The NFTA has said it expects to seek proposals for second-level development. Savarino is asking a judge to say the old exclusive deal never actually ended.