Washington, D.C./ Politics & Govt

SC's Andrews Still Undecided on Schumer vs. Van Hollen Ahead of Dec. 1 Vote

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
SC's Andrews Still Undecided on Schumer vs. Van Hollen Ahead of Dec. 1 VoteSource: Stimpus1 / Wikimedia Commons

South Carolina's incoming U.S. senator says she still hasn't made up her mind on one of the biggest questions facing Senate Democrats right now: who should lead them. Annie Andrews told reporters this week she's undecided between Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer and challenger Chris Van Hollen, even though she had previously vowed not to back Schumer at all.

A Reversal in Tone, If Not Yet in Vote

Before her election, Andrews said flatly that she would not vote for Schumer as majority leader, according to the South Carolina Daily Gazette. Now, as the Dec. 1 caucus vote approaches, she says she is still having conversations with both Schumer and Van Hollen, as reported by The Post and Courier. Andrews said she wants to use those conversations to talk about her priorities for South Carolina, per the same report, and to see how either candidate might help her deliver for her constituents.

The Gazette's report notes Andrews is meeting with both men before she decides who gets her support — Schumer, 75, and Van Hollen, 67. Schumer previously served as majority leader from 2021 to 2025, and the vote that will decide the next leader of the Senate Democratic caucus is scheduled for Dec. 1, conducted by secret ballot, as detailed by The New York Times.

Where the Race Stands Heading Into December

Schumer told reporters he's confident he'll keep his post, saying, “I'm confident I'll be the next leader. I have the votes,” according to The Hill. Van Hollen, for his part, says he has 15 votes lined up, though at the time of that report only four Democrats set to vote in the Dec. 1 election had publicly announced their support for him. The Times reported that a small group of Democrats favor a change in leadership but haven't firmly committed to backing Van Hollen, leaving the outcome genuinely uncertain.

The Associated Press framed the contest as one that is forcing Senate Democrats to take sides, a dynamic that helps explain why Andrews' undecided status is drawing attention. Her hesitation fits into a broader pattern: several newly elected Democrats have aired reservations about backing Schumer for majority leader, according to ABC News 4.

Andrews Frames Herself as Part of a 'Generational Change'

Andrews is one of 11 freshman Democrats entering the Senate next year, and she has described that class as representing a generational change, the Post and Courier reported. She said in late October that both parties are ready for a new generation of leadership, according to the Daily Gazette, and that freshman senators will be part of a group that breaks the “norms of the way the Senate functions.”

Those comments track with what Andrews told voters on the campaign trail. Speaking to Politico earlier this month, she said constituents repeatedly raised the cost of gas and groceries, along with rural hospital closures in South Carolina, as top concerns heading into her term. Those are the kinds of issues she says she wants Schumer and Van Hollen to address as she weighs her vote for Senate leadership.