Orlando/ Crime & Emergencies

Seminole County Cold Case Cracked — Michigan Runaway Named 52 Years After Lake Lotus Discovery

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Seminole County Cold Case Cracked — Michigan Runaway Named 52 Years After Lake Lotus DiscoveryBreezy Pines RV Estates — Reported Site of Separate Remains Identification
Google Street View

A Michigan teenager who vanished more than five decades ago has finally been given her name back. Investigators say remains found in a wooded area off Forest City Road in unincorporated Altamonte Springs in August 1973 belong to Marianne Hartman, a runaway last seen alive in Daytona Beach, closing out one of Seminole County's longest-running cold cases.

Hartman was one of two young women discovered in the area that month, according to WFTV Channel 9 Orlando. The other victim, 18-year-old Orlando hospital technician Laura Lynn Harberts, was identified decades earlier through dental records, according to the Orlando Sentinel. She was found off Forest City Road near Lake Lotus that same August, the newspaper reported, while Hartman's identity eluded investigators for more than 50 years.

According to WFTV, detectives got a breakthrough earlier this year when a distant relative researching their own family tree surfaced evidence that helped crack the case. An investigator told the station that the genealogical connection was key to finally putting a name to the second victim, whose remains have now been returned to relatives for burial after more than five decades.

A Decades-Old Mystery Tied to a Notorious Suspect

The cases trace back to Joseph Spaziano, known as “Crazy Joe,” a Central Florida biker gang member described by WFTV as responsible for chaos, murder, sexual batteries and other associated crimes. Witnesses reported seeing a teenage girl matching Hartman's description with Spaziano around the time of the killings. Separately, a witness told investigators she recalled seeing Spaziano with a young girl in Daytona Beach in the spring of 1973 and later remembered the girl was from Ann Arbor, Michigan, according to Uncovered.

Spaziano was convicted in 1976 of Harberts' death and was not charged in the second woman's death, the Orlando Sentinel reported at the time. Per WFTV, he later pleaded no contest to second-degree murder in Harberts' case and was sentenced to life in prison, where he remains today in his 80s and is reportedly experiencing advanced cognitive decline.

For years, the second victim's identity remained one of the case's most frustrating gaps. In a 2018 report, the Sentinel noted that investigators hoped new DNA testing methods would help identify the girl, and that isotope testing had determined she was likely from the Pacific Northwest. The case page on Uncovered similarly described chemical isotope testing suggesting she was born in the Pacific Northwest or western United States and had lived in the Midwest before her death.

Genetic Genealogy's Growing Role in Florida Cold Cases

Hartman's identification adds to a string of recent cold-case breakthroughs across Florida built on investigative genetic genealogy and public DNA databases. In the Florida Keys, the Monroe County Sheriff's Office and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement identified two sets of long-unidentified remains earlier this year using the technique. One set, found on Big Pine Key in 2017, was confirmed as James Donald Schlake, 77, of Key Largo, after genetic relatives were located in December 2025. The FDLE used advanced genetic genealogy in collaboration with the DNA laboratory Othram Inc. to help make that identification, funded in part through the State Forensic Investigative Genetic Genealogy Grant Fund.

A second Keys case, remains found at Breezy Pines RV Estates in 2014, was identified as Igor Kolomiets, 52, of Big Pine Key, using fingerprint checks with the FBI and U.S. Border Patrol rather than genealogy. Nationally, CNN has reported similar success stories, including the identification of “Chelsea Jane Doe” as Tiffany Bradley nearly 26 years after she vanished in November 2000, and the identification of Cheryl Lynn Edwards, who was 15 when she disappeared roughly 50 years before her remains were found in the Mississippi River in 1975. CNN noted that in both of those cases, investigators relied on public DNA databases to reveal the teenagers' true identities, and that the DNA Doe Project advises agencies to budget up to $10,900 per case for lab fees and DNA profile processing.

For the family that spent half a century not knowing what happened to their daughter, the breakthrough closes a painful chapter. Marianne Hartman's remains have now been returned to relatives for burial, bringing a measure of resolution to a case that began in a wooded stretch of Seminole County in the summer of 1973.