
A $1,589 damage bill from rental giant SIXT was dropped for a Colorado man who swore he never scratched a Buick he rented at Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport. Christopher Nienhuis had disputed the charge, filed complaints and braced for it to hit his credit score — until SIXT dropped the claim, about a week after reporters contacted the company.
Nienhuis rented the Buick from SIXT at Mitchell Airport in October, and the company later sent him an invoice citing black splatter along the license plate and siding near the tires, plus white scuffing around the rear windshield, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's Public Investigator team, as reported by Yahoo. Nienhuis maintained he did not damage the car and said the black splatter looked like it could simply be washed off. He disputed the bill, filed a report with the Better Business Bureau, and contacted Wisconsin's consumer protection agency before reporters got involved.
Then, as Public Investigator pressed SIXT for answers, the company dropped the claim entirely — about a week after being contacted, per the same report. SIXT has not explained why it reversed course, and it has not responded to requests for comment on the matter. Nienhuis told the outlet he was relieved the bill no longer threatened his credit score, adding simply, “Thank you for your help.”
Nearly $500 in Fees Wisconsin Law Doesn't Allow
Buried in Nienhuis's bill were charges that regulators say shouldn't have been there in the first place. Nearly $500 of his damage claim was made up of appraisal, administrative and diminution-of-value fees — the kind of add-ons the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection says state law prohibits outright, per the department's account relayed in the same report. Under Wisconsin statute, a renter's financial responsibility is generally capped at reasonable repair costs or the car's fair market value, whichever is less.
Wisconsin law prohibits rental companies from imposing administrative charges, including appraisal costs, along with other incidental costs. Nienhuis wasn't alone — Public Investigator found that SIXT had charged four Wisconsin customers fees it said are not allowed under state law, after those renters separately reported damage claims they believed were bogus.
Regulators Say They'll Push for Compliance
DATCP told Public Investigator that if any violations of Wisconsin law are identified during its mediation with SIXT, the department will address them in an effort to secure compliance in future transactions, the report states. The agency's own guidance on car rentals and collision damage waivers notes that the rules discussed apply only within Wisconsin, meaning renters elsewhere can't necessarily lean on the same statute.
SIXT, which the report says operates 59 airport locations across 35 states, still has not answered whether it plans to stop charging Wisconsin customers these disputed fees. By contrast, a Hertz spokesperson said in an October email that Wisconsin locations of Hertz, Dollar Car Rental and Thrifty Car Rental — all owned by Hertz — do not charge customers for loss of use, diminished value, an appraisal or an administrative fee when a vehicle is damaged.
A Pattern Beyond Wisconsin
The Milwaukee case isn't an isolated complaint. WRAL reported finding dozens of SIXT customers nationwide describing strikingly similar large charges for nearly identical rim scratches. One North Carolina renter told the station an employee said “You're good to go” during his return inspection, only for SIXT to send him a photo of a 10-centimeter rim scratch a week later, along with a bill covering a rim, tire, front-end alignment, and administrative and invoice fees. That renter said SIXT never provided timestamped photos or proof the damage happened during his rental, and SIXT told WRAL it stood behind the claim but closed it “as a courtesy to the customer.”
WRAL also noted that a class-action lawsuit accusing SIXT of billing customers for fake damage ended in an $11.07 million settlement, though it covered only renters from 2019 or earlier. Under that settlement, eligible class members who filed valid claims could recover 70% of the disputed damage charges they'd paid, according to a notice posted on American Legal. It's worth noting that Wisconsin's specific fee prohibitions have not been shown to apply in other states, even where similar billing complaints have surfaced.
What Wisconsin Renters Can Do
Drivers who suspect they've been hit with unlawful fees are encouraged to file a complaint with Wisconsin's Bureau of Consumer Protection. Complaints can be submitted online at consumerprotection.wi.gov, by calling the consumer protection hotline at (800) 422-7128, or by emailing [email protected]. Renters filing a complaint should include their rental agreement, the damage invoice, and all correspondence with the rental company. The Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection notes that complaints submitted to the agency are not confidential and may be subject to a public records request.









