Greenville/ Politics & Govt

South Carolina Teachers Pocket $5.5M in Bonuses, Push for Permanent Pay Plan

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
South Carolina Teachers Pocket $5.5M in Bonuses, Push for Permanent Pay PlanSource: Salvationistdan / Wikimedia Commons

More than 750 South Carolina public school teachers split a combined $5.5 million in performance-based bonuses last school year, and the state's top education official now wants to make the payouts a permanent fixture rather than a year-to-year gamble. The bonuses, tied to how much students improve over the course of a school year, stretched across 97 participating schools, with every one of those schools producing at least one award winner.

State Superintendent Ellen Weaver plans to ask lawmakers for recurring funding that would lock the program in starting with the 2027-2028 school year, according to SC Daily Gazette. The outlet reports that the evidence does not yet show lawmakers have approved that request — for now, the program is continuing into a third school year after the General Assembly allocated another $5 million for awards this cycle. “Great teachers change lives,” Weaver said in a news release cited by the Gazette, adding that performance bonuses “help keep teachers in classrooms” and that recognizing excellence matters.

Weaver's broader goal, per the same report, is what she called a sustainable, permanent approach to teacher compensation — one designed to both attract new educators and retain the effective ones already in South Carolina classrooms. The state is working to ensure its compensation system reflects the value of teachers, and education leaders have separately pushed for laws aimed at easing red tape, adding planning time, and making classrooms safer, the Gazette notes.

How the Bonuses Are Calculated

Bonuses are calculated based on how much a teacher's students improve over the course of the year, but the exact measurement tool depends on which school a teacher works in. Participating schools can use the Excellence in Teaching Awards model, which compares student test performance at the start and end of the year, or rely on SC Ready results — the standardized test given to every public third- through eighth-grader in South Carolina. Schools can also design their own bonus measurement model, including end-of-course tests for high schoolers.

The Excellence in Teaching Awards approach traces back to 2021, when it began in Charleston County's Meeting Street Schools, a public-private partnership funded by philanthropist Ben Navarro, according to the Gazette. That model has since expanded well beyond its original campuses, per a separate SC Daily Gazette report, which found 526 teachers across 39 schools earning more than $4.6 million through that specific model, with an average award of $8,800. One Brentwood teacher, Sydney Carroll, took home $57,250 through the Excellence in Teaching Awards program, that earlier report found.

Darlington Middle School's Standout Numbers

Nowhere did the program land harder than at Darlington Middle School, where 20 teachers earned a combined $254,490 in performance bonuses, according to WPDE. More than 90% of eligible teachers at the school earned an award — the highest share among schools using the SC Ready-based growth model — with an average payout topping $12,000, the station reported.

Darlington School District Superintendent Matthew Ferguson said the results reflect more than just test scores. “The results reflect students learning more, becoming stronger readers and problem-solvers, and building future skills,” he said, according to the Gazette's reporting. The district serves a student population where more than 89% live in poverty, and its three participating schools saw more than 90% of teachers receive bonuses — numbers WPDE's report frames as evidence the model can work even in high-poverty settings. The South Carolina Department of Education secured $5 million from the General Assembly to keep the pilot running with its current participating schools through the 2026-27 school year, per WPDE's account.

Equity Concerns and Uneven Rewards

Not every teacher has an equal shot at a bonus. Available bonus models do not apply to all teachers, and advocates have pointed out that music and arts teachers often lack the kind of standardized tests used to measure student progress in other subjects. Those same advocates have called for a more equitable way of rewarding teachers across every discipline, the Gazette reports.

The payouts also vary widely by region. In Allendale and Williamsburg counties, average performance-bonus payments topped $5,000 last year, with the largest single bonus reaching nearly $30,000, according to The Post and Courier. The program's statewide footprint has grown fast: the state-run pilot reached 37 schools and roughly 400 teachers in an earlier year with $2.5 million in awards, before scaling up to the 97-school, 750-teacher, $5.5 million figures reported this year, with an average individual award of $8,000.

Scores Climbing, Salaries Also Rising

The bonus push comes as South Carolina reports improved test scores over the last few school years. Just over 61% of third- through eighth-graders read on grade level during the 2025-2026 school year, and nearly 48% performed math on grade level that same year — both reading and math scores improved from the previous school year, per the Gazette's report.

Teacher pay has been climbing alongside the bonus program. South Carolina lawmakers raised the minimum first-year teacher salary to $50,500 for the 2026-2027 school year, up from $48,500 the year before, according to the Gazette's reporting. Whether the bonus program itself becomes a permanent part of that compensation picture now rests on the funding request Weaver plans to bring to lawmakers.