Philadelphia/ Real Estate & Development

South Orange Couple Turns 1860 Homestead Into Boutique Hotel, Restaurant

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
South Orange Couple Turns 1860 Homestead Into Boutique Hotel, RestaurantSource: Famartin / Wikimedia Commons

A 166-year-old homestead along River Road in West Amwell Township is set to become a boutique hotel and restaurant, after the South Orange couple behind it traced the idea back to a single question they asked themselves on a Maine vacation. Michael Ehrenreich and Rebecca Gelman plan to convert the 1860 Federal-style house and its carriage barn into the Quarry House Inn, with 10 suites, a 17-seat restaurant, and produce grown on their own nearby farm.

As reported by Jersey Digs, the couple received municipal approval to convert the homestead, located on Route 29 in West Amwell Township, into the hotel and restaurant. The property sits across Route 29 from the Delaware and Raritan Canal State Park Trail and the Delaware River, and it will neighbor Big Bear Gear, the couple's existing outdoor shop that sells clothing and rents bicycles and kayaks. Ehrenreich is the medical director of Soma Skin & Laser, while Gelman is an architect at Gelman Architecture, and together they also own Bellemont Farm, which Jersey Digs reports will supply farm-to-table produce to the new restaurant.

A Maine Motor Lodge Sparked the Idea

Ehrenreich has said the hotel concept followed a vacation at a converted motor lodge in Maine, where he recalled asking Gelman, “you know, why don't we do something like that?” The following year, per the same account, the couple vacationed at a similar converted motor lodge in Cape May, reinforcing the idea before they went looking for a property of their own.

The search led them to a 7.4-acre parcel near Lambertville. This isn't the pair's first attempt at this kind of project in West Amwell: the township had approved a similar venture called the General's Retreat for the couple roughly eight years earlier, but Ehrenreich has said the pandemic delayed that project's execution.

A Property With Roots Back to 1765

Records cited in a commission report trace the property's history well before the couple's involvement. The Stout family acquired the property in 1765 and purchased the Upper Bellemont Farm property, according to that report. A local couple bought the property in 1860, and the dwelling itself was built after that 1860 sale, per the commission report. A local quarrying industry leader bought the property in 1892, and it was later sold in 1930 to Frances Fireman, wife of Trenton industrialist Peter Fireman, according to the same report.

What the Renovation Will Include

The project is planned in two phases. The first includes renovation of the carriage barn and a 1,513-square-foot expansion of the house, while the second adds a 1,252-square-foot addition to the house for the restaurant. When finished, the inn will place eight rooms in the main house and two more in the carriage barn. Plans also call for a bike path connecting the hotel to Big Bear Gear.

Ehrenreich has said the renovation is intended to preserve the homestead's historic details while still feeling modern. He estimated the project will take about a year to complete once ground is broken, and said he hopes the work gets underway soon, though he declined to disclose the project's estimated cost.

Public Concerns Raised at Hearing

Not everyone welcomed the plans without reservation. Members of the public raised concerns about noise, odors, traffic, and environmental issues during the board hearing on the application, according to Jersey Digs' reporting. West Amwell Township's Land Use Board agenda for a May 19 meeting separately listed a completeness and public hearing for 1872 River Road, LLC's Quarry House application regarding final site plan approval, according to the West Amwell Township Land Use Board agenda, which also listed township services to the LLC for March 2026.

A separate, low-confidence excerpt from July 2023 minutes of the Delaware and Raritan Canal Commission notes that a Dr. Ehrenreich introduced himself as the project applicant and thanked the commission for approving a carriage barn project, though the minutes are truncated and don't establish the full context of that approval.