Tampa/ Crime & Emergencies

St. Petersburg Houseboat Killer Rejected Jury, Judge Hands Him Death Again

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
St. Petersburg Houseboat Killer Rejected Jury, Judge Hands Him Death AgainPinellas County Circuit Court — Resentencing Proceedings Venue
Google Street View

Reynaldo Figueroa-Sanabria was sentenced to death a second time for the 2013 stabbing deaths of John Travlos and Germana Morin aboard their St. Petersburg houseboat, after waiving his right to a jury, doctors, and family testimony during a resentencing hearing before Pinellas County Circuit Judge Pat Siracusa Jr. He told the judge he wanted to appeal whatever sentence came down, according to reporting detailed by the Tampa Free Press.

Figueroa-Sanabria was originally convicted of the two first-degree murders and sentenced to death on each count in 2019, after a jury unanimously recommended death, according to the Florida Supreme Court opinion, hosted by Justia. The court found that Morin and Travlos were stabbed to death early in the morning of April 12, 2013 on their houseboat in St. Petersburg. In 2023, the Florida Supreme Court set aside those death sentences and sent the case back for a new penalty phase, ruling that the trial court had improperly put Figueroa-Sanabria to a choice at the outset of that proceeding, forcing him to pick between presenting mitigation evidence with a lawyer or representing himself, per the Tampa Free Press.

A Defendant Who Chose To Go It Alone

At the resentencing, Figueroa-Sanabria declined a jury, declined doctor testimony, and declined family testimony, the Tampa Free Press reports. His attorney, Daniel Hernandez, warned him that a jury recommendation was his only realistic shot at a life sentence, but Figueroa-Sanabria said he understood he was disregarding that advice. He rejected the judge's final offer to summon a jury before the hearing and told Judge Siracusa the court could sentence him immediately, just as he had requested two and a half weeks earlier.

Judge Siracusa observed that Figueroa-Sanabria was polite and attentive throughout the proceedings and passed notes to his legal team, according to the same reporting. In imposing the death sentences on May 13, 2024, Siracusa cited five aggravating factors, including that the murders were committed for financial gain, were especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, and that the victims were elderly and disabled. A separate account from tampabay.com states that Judge Siracusa made his decision on May 15, while another report places the resentencing itself on May 13 — the evidence does not explain the discrepancy between the two dates.

Appeal Centered On Mental Fitness To Waive A Jury

Figueroa-Sanabria's appellate team argued that Siracusa should have ordered a new competency evaluation before allowing him to waive a jury, and separately contended that his jury waiver was not knowing and intelligent because it left little for an appeals court to review. A court-appointed expert had found him competent in 2019, and Siracusa said he had observed Figueroa-Sanabria for seven years without seeing signs of mental decline, according to the Tampa Free Press. Hernandez reportedly said he had no argument that his client was mentally incapable of waiving his rights.

The Florida Supreme Court rejected the claim that Figueroa-Sanabria was not mentally fit to waive a jury during resentencing and upheld his death sentences for the 2013 murders. Writing for the majority, Justice Renatha Francis stated that a defendant need only understand the right being waived, not possess an appellate attorney's legal knowledge, per the Tampa Free Press's account of the ruling. Chief Justice John Couriel and Justices Carlos Muñiz, Jamie Grosshans, Barrios, and Adam Tanenbaum joined the majority opinion.

A Concurrence Over Proportionality Review

Justice Jorge Labarga agreed with the outcome but wrote separately, reiterating his long-standing objection to the court's 2020 decision to end comparative proportionality review — the practice of weighing death sentences against other capital cases to assess fairness — according to the same reporting. The underlying statute, found in the 2024 Florida Statutes, requires a separate sentencing proceeding after a capital felony conviction to determine whether a defendant receives death or life imprisonment.

Figueroa-Sanabria's case has now moved through two rounds of sentencing and a Florida Supreme Court review of how far a defendant can go in representing himself at the most consequential stage of a capital case. With the high court's ruling upholding the sentences, the resentencing imposed by Judge Siracusa in Pinellas County stands.

Tampa-Crime & Emergencies