New York City/ Crime & Emergencies

Suffolk County Finally Names 6 Cold Case Victims Found Since 1976

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 15, 2026
Suffolk County Finally Names 6 Cold Case Victims Found Since 1976Source: Suffolk County District Attorney

Six people whose remains sat unidentified in Suffolk County for as long as 50 years finally have their names back. Officials announced the identifications Thursday during a press conference at the police training facility in Brentwood, revealing the names of six individuals found in cases stretching from 1976 to 1999, three of whom were homicide victims.

According to the Suffolk County District Attorney, the six are Ramon Perez y Rivera, Sofia Margherita Marrone, Antoinette Rugg, Kyong-Ok Kim, Omelios Steward, and Andreas Kupke. The DA’s office said three of the six were homicide victims, restoring names to people who had been known by pseudonyms for decades. Family members attended Thursday’s press conference as officials laid out how each identification came together.

Gunshot Wound in Deer Park Led to Decades-Long Mystery

The earliest case involves Ramon Perez y Rivera, who was found in Deer Park on November 27, 1976. Per the Suffolk County DA, he died from a gunshot wound to his lower right abdomen. The New York Post reports that Perez y Rivera, previously known as Raymond Doe, was from Puerto Rico and had lived in South Williamsburg, Brooklyn, in 1950, and that he was 41 years old.

Antoinette Rugg, found at Heckscher State Park on April 2, 1978, was determined by the medical examiner to have died from strangulation, according to the same DA account. She was 26 years old at the time of her death and had a 10-year-old son, officials said. The Post reports she had also been known as the Heckscher Jane Doe and that a dog had dug up a human skull in Islip in 1978 before her remains were later recovered.

A Riverhead Jane Doe and a Fire Island Discovery

Kyong-Ok Kim was found in Riverhead on March 12, 1990, and her cause of death remains under investigation, the DA’s office said. The Post reports she was from South Korea and was 32 years old, and that she had previously been referred to as the Riverhead Jane Doe.

Omelios Steward was identified through advances in fingerprint analysis, according to the DA’s office, after he was found in the Atlantic Ocean near Fire Island on November 4, 1990. Officials believe his death was caused by drowning. Sources differ on his age at death — the DA’s account states he was 28, while Newsday reports he was 26 — and the discrepancy had not been resolved as of Thursday’s announcement.

Andreas Kupke, a German citizen, was found dead near Ditch Plains in Montauk on Christmas Eve 1999, according to 27east. His cause of death remains unclear, the outlet reports, and he was identified after nearly 27 years without a name.

‘Montauk Mary’ Case Raises Thrill Killer Questions

The case drawing the most attention is that of the woman long known as Montauk Mary. Newsday reports investigators identified her as Sofia Margherita Marrone, of Pleasantville, New Jersey, who was found near Montauk Highway on March 22, 1978, with four gunshot wounds, according to the Suffolk County DA. The Post reports she was 73 years old and had last been seen leaving Shore Memorial Hospital in New Jersey days before her body turned up hours from home on Long Island.

Investigators have pointed to Richard Biegenwald, a convicted killer known as the Thrill Killer who murdered at least six victims across the Jersey Shore before dying in prison in 2008, as a possible suspect in Marrone’s death, per the Post. Per 27east, the DA said the weapon and rare style of bullets used to kill Marrone matched those found by New Jersey police when they arrested Biegenwald in 1983. Investigators described Biegenwald as a very likely killer, but 27east reports they have not been able to definitively link him to Marrone’s murder through DNA or other forensic evidence.

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney said authorities had made progress restoring the victims’ identities and advancing justice, according to the Post. The Post also reports that DNA testing, the same type of forensic technology that helped apprehend Rex Heuermann in 2023, was used in some of the six cold case identifications announced Thursday.

Hundreds of Cases Still Await Answers

The six identifications are part of a broader effort that began in 2024, when Suffolk County announced a dedicated Cold Case Unit. At the time, Newsday reported the unit was expected to review roughly 300 death investigations dating back to 1965, staffed by 15 employees working alongside Suffolk homicide investigators, with plans to bring on a genetic genealogist.

Tierney’s office has pledged to continue working to identify the remaining victims.